Underground has had some problems as well. I don't know much about the Brew House.
The Craft Beer market would probably be the best of these options. I like the atmosphere there.
Take a look at how much they charge as well for getting in if price is any issue. Craft usually has a good crowd. Things don't tend to go sideways there because of the clientele, operation, and who they market to. Seems to be a professional crowd but not pretentious. Just a nice space, lots of room, good service. Might pay a bit more there. On NYE especially its important not to end up in a dive. Word of mouth is not to stay anywhere till last call although you would be fine in Craft. Problems invariably occur at other establishments or districts at last call. Understand as well that UBER will likely have surge pricing on NYE as they often have (I think they still do this) and you could end up paying more than you expect. Cabs hard to come by. Busses run late if it helps.
Just checked, Craft is charging 70-80 bucks for a NYE dinner and dance. Pretty standard. I haven't ate much there so can't vouch for food but have heard good things.