Super Team Tournament Voting [Rof16 complete]

[Ainec]

Boston - easily
LAK - semi close. Won due to fwd depth

Dal vs Mtl - closest matchup so far. Cbf to vote and look into it for more than 20 seconds

 

[hockeynorth]

Yeah since it is public go ahead. For the PM vote I wasn't counting them.

Can we change them or should I hold off until I'm locked in?

 

[hockeynorth]

Boston - easily
LAK - semi close. Won due to fwd depth

Dal vs Mtl - closest matchup so far. Cbf to vote and look into it for more than 20 seconds

...I put a ton of time judging every one of these matchups guys just so thats clear

 

[Makaveli]

Can we change them or should I hold off until I'm locked in?

We can change them, for errors and debating purposes.

 

[hockeynorth]

We can change them, for errors and debating purposes.

Perfect, I'll cast my votes for now then!

 

[Ainec]

Wpg - close, ultimately mcdavid + rask over barkov + bishop and slightly stronger wings

Vgk - much better d, makes up for weaker f

VAN - NYR - not a fan of both teams lol

 

[hockeynorth]

The VAN-NYR matchup is actually the one I'm struggling with the most, surprised its so lopsided. I prefer NYR if they'd fixed their lines.

Also who picked Ottawa

 

[Ainec]

Looks like I'm bang on with the votes. Even the matchup that I said was closest is tied 3-3.

Only WPG is where my vote diverges as CBJ is winning by a large margin

 

[hockeynorth]

Boston is just cleaning out their matchup man, poor @Kent Nilsson I liked your knights team but you had no high end C depth

 

[hockeynorth]

Thought Arizona and Colorado would be closer though, @m0pe's D first team isn't that much of a clear cut winner for me. I'd really like to hear some other peoples thoughts on each matchup though

 

[Kent Nilsson]

Boston is just cleaning out their matchup man, poor @Kent Nilsson I liked your knights team but you had no high end C depth

 

[m0pe]

Thought Arizona and Colorado would be closer though, @m0pe's D first team isn't that much of a clear cut winner for me. I'd really like to hear some other peoples thoughts on each matchup though

Overall game > Points.

I am not saying mine is clear cut best team, but i have Arizona as one of the weaker teams due to their D and don't think I am being too biased putting myself ahead of him.

 

[Ainec]

After looking at DAL and MTL more the only fair vote is a tie.

Sometimes matchups are 50-50. Flip a coin/whoever has home ice

 

[hockeynorth]

Overall game > Points.

I am not saying mine is clear cut best team, but i have Arizona as one of the weaker teams due to their D and don't think I am being too biased putting myself ahead of him.

I had you and Arizona in a tier together pretty much with you just having the edge, was kind of funny it came out as a match up, I just didn't think you'd win so cleanly. Will be curious where your team stops winning, I feel like a really deep offensive team would push back a lot more.

 

[hockeynorth]

true sweepppppppppp incoming

Update... we no longer have a prospective sweep. I'll be considering one vote for a team a sweep from here on out, as most would vote their own team

 

[hockeynorth]

After looking at DAL and MTL more the only fair vote is a tie.

Sometimes matchups are 50-50. Flip a coin/whoever has home ice

It's a question of depth vs star power I feel like, and I'm taking the depth in that match up (right now)

 

[Makaveli]

Funny how the bracket turned out. Battle of Ontario and also Strome vs Strome battle is epic as well haha.

 

[Llamamoto]

Wow, I thought I would be a lot closer. Vegas starting to run away with this.

Vote for Edmonton!

 

[hockeynorth]

Funny how the bracket turned out. Battle of Ontario and also Strome vs Strome battle is epic as well haha.

This bracket is intense man. I'm really feeling switching to NYR over VAN but I'll stay put for now

 

[AveryStar4Eva]

I'm fine with both options.

The Vegas - Edmonton thing is annoying because we both have great teams, but @AveryStar4Eva have a bit more respect for each other than some of the other posters in this thread . We seem to always make trades with each other in GM games, so we want to keep that relationship lol.

Friendship first, rivalry second!

 

[m0pe]

Wow, I thought I would be a lot closer. Vegas starting to run away with this.

Vote for Edmonton!

to me this was the closest one but stuck with Vegas by a hair for now.

I may or may not accept bribes to change my mind...

 

[hockeynorth]

Don't forget Toronto has the likeliest Norris winner and likeliest Vezina winner who should also get MVP on their team... just saying

 

[Makaveli]

I'm not sold on the EDM-VEG and MTL-DAL match-ups.

 

[Llamamoto]

I'm not sold on the EDM-VEG and MTL-DAL match-ups.

You can always change the matchups....

 

[hockeynorth]

I'm not sold on the EDM-VEG and MTL-DAL match-ups.

EDM-VEG, MTL-DAL, VAN-NYR, ARI-COL are all matchups I could be flipped in, so half. Only really locked in for BOS-NYI (not cause I particularly like Bostons team, they're not in my top tier but look at the match up), TOR-OTT, LA-DET