Ol' Ripper is correct.
And the funny part (unless you're Sheahan or his agent) is Rutherford didn't qualify him for fear of what arbitration numbers could bring. He was well placed to find some security in terms of money and term.
Instead he came back here for a 1 year contract with dubious prospects and ruined that. Which was entirely predictable. Unless he thought Brassard wouldn't be at 3C, it makes no sense. He should have taken term, here or elsewhere.
If we pay him 3m next year, he's probably been a big part of a playoff run, because I don't see what else he could to justify that by now. I guess lets hope for it then
While I share this doubt, having Kessel on the 3rd is the quickest way to turn a good pairing that drives play mostly the right way into a positive force, because he can bring the finishing touch. In comparison, he very rarely elevates Sid or Geno much beyond what they can do with lesser linemates anyway.