So what are you and others suggesting? If it's that we need another "primary" winger, that's fine, but pretty unrealistic.
Otherwise, I'm confused what the alternative options are to our current situation. My view is we have enough skill and quality on the wings to be contenders.
My issue with the forwards group is the same that was before the start of the season.
It was discussed on this board last season too. Lots of good players on paper, but the mix doesn't seem right.
The only undoubtable fit in top 6 is Guentzel-Crosby, imo.
For me three of Hornqvist, Kessel and Rust are each better suited in a 3rd line RW role.
Just to spitball, something that can be tried
Guentzel-Crosby-Hornqvist
x-Malkin-Simon
Pearson-x-Kessel
x-Cullen-Rust
Trade Brassard+ for a RW or LW for Geno (ironically Hagelin could fit on the left, but Malkin hasn't been allowed to play with a skilled winger like Simon until very recently, if Phil isn't on his line).
If there no deal for a 3C, slide Sheahan there.
Maybe in the playoffs Sid will be ok with idea of Horny on his line again.