Oh i see, so the award should go to who’s out the longest and not for the effort they take to get back as soon as possible. You are okay to give it to McDavid if he followed the long rehab the doctors wanted to do rather than the hard risky path he took to not miss a game.
Everyone is entitled to their opinion. If giving an award based on time (Guess its easy then, just pick the longest time out) or who had the most serious injury but may have done nothing other than rest to get better is your thing, then great. To me you give an award to someone that goes above and beyond the norm to come back as soon as possible. To each their own guess.