1. Murray at 1 is either extremely logical and right, or an atrocious case of overrating. It really depends on who you're asking, but I'm leaning more towards the latter option. A top 10 choice for sure, but Murray shouldn't be in the top 5.
2. Forsberg is extremely good - not many have proven both goalscoring talent and solid two-way play at his age. Very accurate.
3. Galchenyuk... yeah, he should definitely be lower, even if he is leading the draft class in points and games played.
4. Personally, I have Lindholm at 1. That's me being high on him, and for a damn good reason. The guy is awesome.
5. Rielly is a tad too high.
6. Oh my. TT is not even the best 2012 draftee who plays for the Canes. What a dumpster fire of a choice at 6.
7. Ghost is a solid pick, but not solid enough to warrant the seventh spot (he's close, though). That being said, I assume that his rookie season is still raising some eyebrows among those who submit these lists.
8. I think Murray barely belongs to the top 10. You might be able to figure out my take on Vasi based on that.
9. What a steal of a pick in the original draft. 9 might be low by a slot or two in the redraft.
10. I guess Hertl is ranked a bit too high.
11. This is a travesty. One of the two clear 1Ds of the draft at this point, who should be an unanimous top 3 choice.
12. I have no problems with this.
13. Murray > Andersen > Vasi. For real though, comparing goalies to skaters is so damn tough, especially when the criterion couldn't be more vague than this.
14. This draft wasn't good for those who were in need of forwards. Pearson is easily a first rounder in the redraft, although I would put him closer to 20 than 10.
15. I find Skjei's rookie year overrated - he faced easy minutes and got his chances to produce. I want to see more of him in a more difficult role before putting him as high as most would.
16. I thought I was offended by Trouba being at 11. Now I am.
Maybe lists are just name recognition after all. For me, Slavin is at 4.
From 17 and onwards, I really don't know enough about the guys to comment on them. My list:
1. Lindholm
2. Forsberg
3. Trouba
4. Slavin
5. Parayko
6. Rielly
7. Galchenyuk
8. Murray
9. Gostisbehere
10. Määttä
11. Murray
12. Severson
13. Andersen
14. Hertl
15. Skjei
16. Dumba
17. Matheson
18. Ceci
19. Vasilevskiy
20. Pearson