Ya I don’t really get why anyone cares. If any third rounder becomes an impactful nhl player it’s a home run. It’s rare. And has anyone even seen him play? It’s hard to form opinions based on central scouting. Are they right with their rankings at the end of round three? They took a big centre who plays a 200 foot game according to the internet. Who knows. Let’s check back in 5 years see where he is.
From the 2013 draft: Brett Pesche, Pavel Buchnevich, Jake Guentzel, Anthony Duclair, Carter Verhaeghe, Oliver Bjorkstrand
From the 2014 draft: Elvis Merzlikins, Ilya Sorokin, Brayden Point, Jake Walman
From the 2015 draft: Anthony Cirelli, Dan Vladar, Aidan Hill, Tommy Novak
From the 2016 draft: Adam Fox, Josh Anderson,
From the 2017 draft: Stuart Skinner
Fromthe 2018 draft: Jack McBain, Jordan Harris
A couple of stars, some good players, a couple of players like Walman and Novak who had a very late success this year as 26 year olds. There are some other NHL players from those drafts but they are 12th-13th F or 7 D types. Still a couple guys from 17 and 18 who could be late bloomers but most likely not. But obviously the odds are against picking someone really good.
So yeah, the success rate isn't high. But the majority of the ones who were successful picks (Fox, Buchnevich, Guentzel, Duclair, Verhaeghe, Bjorkstrand, Point were guys who flashed skill in juniors.
Picking a guy who was 11th in scoring on his USHL team is really not an effective strategy. If you can't score against your peers it's very likely that will continue or worsen at the next level. If you don't have a 1st or 2nd rd pick it's better to swing for a big time scorer who maybe has some other flaws. If you are going to "throw a dart" you might as well aim at a bullseye and not the lowest point spot on the board. A better dart throw would be Jayden Perron. Like all 3rd rd picks it's better odds that he doesn't make it than he does... but if he does he'll be a scoring offensive player. I'd rather risk on that then risk an upside of getting a 4th liner.
Not up and arms about it just saying I don't think he was the best player on the board.