Here is another idea no one has talked about. What about going after Methot and Karlson?
Years ago Washington was brutal on D. They went into FA and got Niskanen and Orpik. Greatly improved their D. Obviously Orpik is what he is these days. But with all this cap, if we were to get a top F early in the draft this is another option. In this situation we would move out Murphy most likely.
Its an outside the box idea. We need someone who can play tough 1st or 2nd pair minutes to insulate Keith. We cannot just throw a bunch of rookies out there and say "have fun" if we want them to develop and we want to be competitive. That only should happen if we want to go the route of EDM or Zona and screw up their development. D men should be over ripe rather than rushed into a gong show. Besides, most would prefer to have too many assets rather than a lack of...I like our young D but I see no one on the left side who will be a top 4 D in the next 3 years on a strong team
I would be open to signing just one of the two I mentioned above, but if we got both I think that would be a game changer for our D. Methot would come cheaper as he has had injury problems, but him and Karlson were fantastic together.
If we do not make this offer I surely expect one of the Islanders, PHI, Rangers to offer both these guys deals.
If they both come as a package, I can see Karlson taking 10 to 10.5 and Methot taking 3.5 to 4 on a shorter term deal