It's a rock and a hard place for whatever team signs him.
He is going to demand $10 million or more most likely. Additionally, unlike Price and Lundqvist, Bobrovsky can land and seriously consider - thereby using as leverage - a huge offer from a team like SKA St. Petersburg. Does he want to go to the KHL? No obviously not. But if a Russian team throws something like $13 - $15 million AAV at him and promises Olympic play, it will serve to increase his cost in the NHL even just a little bit. I say that because that's precisely what he and his agent did last time.
That said, it's going to be highly controversial regardless of who signs him. I look at Bobrovsky as an almost guarantee that your team will make the playoffs. Yeah his playoff stats sucks but I think it is due to sample size and who he is facing. Need more games against a team that doesn't end up winning it all.
It's going to be the following (especially if it is Columbus who signs him):
Others: You guys paid too much for a goalie.
CBJ: Yes but we had to.