It's fascinating because the push for the fishsticks jersey seems to be coming from the younger portion of the fanbase, which has no connection to the "glory days". I would guess that the fans who want to ignore that era trend a bit older. I'm in the middle, born in 82 so I'm just young enough to have no recollection of the cup teams, and also of the age that had gotten both iterations of the 90s jerseys and thought both were cool. I also want them to keep trying something new even if they keep screwing it up.
Im with you on that, I'm born in '81 & I was about 12 when we moved to NY. I had no problem with the Fisherman jersey at the time, I was too young to think about it objectively.
My first game at the coliseum, I was in that fishsticks jersey watching as we destroyed the Rangers. It was so much fun & was just stoked to now have the Islanders as my new team. It wasn't til I started hitting my teens when I starting really hearing all the distain for that jersey & started to understand more about what was happening to the franchise & how we became a joke. Thats when my indifference turned to dislike & I was happy to have shifted away from it & I just wanted to pretend it never happened.
But now I'm old enough to just appreciate thats when I met & fell in love with the Islanders. Embrace the giant gaff, & have some fun with it.
I will say this, finally being a contender again helps alot! This was the first year in all my Fandom that my Rangers & Flyers fans friends actually gave the nod of respect. It was nice. Taking out the Penguins & Capitals in the playoffs the last 2 years gave us so much more noticable respect nationally.
Hopefully we keep it going! I have all my faith in Lou & Barry!