Yeah I would be fine with Perrault in the pressbox for most of the year. Thompson may get decent results on the pk but his es results are awful. I'm just sick of icing a fourth line that needs to buried due to it being full of players that all they can do is PK.
I don't know how you effectively measure the results of a player who is taking 60-70% d-zones starts, I don't know if the advanced stats are weighted for such an impact. You wouldn't expect positive results.
Points wise Perreault put up 7-8-15, 2 PPG, -9 in 49 games, Thompson 4-11-15, -1, and 1 SHA, 1 GWG, in 70 combined games. Ice times were similar, though Perreault averaged 1:26 in PP ice time. How Perreault gets above 50% CF ES is still a mystery to me, it doesn't pass the eye test of the player, but sometimes maybe luck or Lurch is on your side.
I am hoping Thompson has a positive impact. We might try to go with a 35+ minutes a night with our our top 2 lines, 15 out of the checking line. So for a 10 minute- line, where 2 mins at least are devoted to PK, I am just hoping for something better than last year, which was plain bad, from beginning to end, whether it be Bourque, Letestu, Appleton, Gustafsson, Luoto, Shore, Perreault (late season), Shaw etc. Appleton was probably the only salvageable one from the pile. Maybe Shore. It would be nice if players like Gustafsson or Suess get looks as well, depending on the type of matchup, but I'm happy we brought in a guy who is respected around the league as a solid leader. Not going to lead in points, but might lead in faceoffs, PK%, and fights this year.
I know you prefer more rounded 4 line hockey, as do I, but that's not the way a Canadian division looks to be shaping up at all.