Strummergas
Regular User
I like (to varying degrees) all those bands (except Pink Floyd). There's just a weird common thread there that somehow elevates those bands into some kind of sacred cow.
I saw Replacements back in the day. Unfortunately, it was the post-Bob Replacements and they were very polished and saccharine.
From what I've heard (too young to have been there), live Bob-era Replacements shows were overrated (unless you like wrecks). There's no question the albums were better when Bob was in the band, but man shambolic doesn't even describe them on some nights back then.