Breakers
Make Mirrored Visors Legal Again
Hopefully TO has a solid PK
Because Bennett loves himself some stupid penalties.
Because Bennett loves himself some stupid penalties.
No, we are not defending anything, we are calling you out for your stupid opinions that you felt the need to tack on and attack Tkachuk withHe was. His point totals were fantastic because of Marner. He was #2 after Marner on MARNER'S LINE. YOU stop changing the subject.
I was responding to a message that Marner be added as a +. Tkachuk is not better than Marner. Marner is not a piece to get Tkachuk. It was a stupid comment and YOU are defending it.
He was. His point totals were fantastic because of Marner. He was #2 after Marner on MARNER'S LINE. YOU stop changing the subject.
I was responding to a message that Marner be added as a +. Tkachuk is not better than Marner. Marner is not a piece to get Tkachuk. It was a stupid comment and YOU are defending it.
Tkachuk is a good valet for MarnerNo, we are not defending anything, we are calling you out for your stupid opinions that you felt the need to tack on and attack Tkachuk with
Your illusionary 100 point Marner?Tkachuk is a good valet for Marner
Want Gaudreau too? Or is that not needed since you have Marner anyways.Switch Bennett with Monahan
Do you honestly think Nylander gets a signed EK?? Nylander is a very good young player but let’s be realistic for a minute. That offer would be beaten by quite a few other teams I’d imagine.
Nylander, Lils and your first might get the conversation started for a signed EK.
I like Calgary . My 2nd favourite team . I don't post much about the Flames as it seems to be taboo to cheer for both AB teams . I got to ask how's a 2 time 60 point forward is overrated ? Sometimes fans overvalue their own players but fans don't make up stat sheets . Overrating is when Flames fans talk about Johnny hockey being on McDavid's level or their D being top 5 in the NHL .Do not want Nylander is Soft and Over-rated.
Tkachuk hamonic for Nylander + something small. Depending on Calgary’s needs
Tkachuk for Nylander
(Willy a bit better, Tkachuk a bit cheaper)
Tkachuk - Matthews - Kapanen
Marleau - - Tavares - - - Marner
Johnsson - - - Kadri - - - Hyman
Gaudreau - Monahan - Nylander
Neal - - - Backlund - - - Lindholm
Bennett - - - Jankowski - - - Frolik
Not going to comment on overall value, but a deal like this simply doesn't work for the Flames. If we are moving Hanifin, we would need Andersson as we don't have another NHL ready defenseman to step in as a regular, even dealing 1 would leave us shit, but both is a definite no go. Also, we literally have zero need for Pickard and adding him gives us too many goalies.Nylander
Nielsen
Pickard
2nd in 20
For
Bennett
Hanifin
Andersson
Value wise, it's probably close, but Tkachuk is the type of player the Flames have needed for a very long time and fits our needs more than Nylander. So, the Flames would pass.Tkachuk for Nylander
(Willy a bit better, Tkachuk a bit cheaper)
Tkachuk - Matthews - Kapanen
Marleau - - Tavares - - - Marner
Johnsson - - - Kadri - - - Hyman
Gaudreau - Monahan - Nylander
Neal - - - Backlund - - - Lindholm
Bennett - - - Jankowski - - - Frolik
Tkachuk for Nylander
(Willy a bit better, Tkachuk a bit cheaper)
Tkachuk - Matthews - Kapanen
Marleau - - Tavares - - - Marner
Johnsson - - - Kadri - - - Hyman
Gaudreau - Monahan - Nylander
Neal - - - Backlund - - - Lindholm
Bennett - - - Jankowski - - - Frolik
Nylander
Nielsen
Pickard
2nd in 20
For
Bennett
Hanifin
Andersson
LulzToronto fans are delusional if they think Nylander lands them Tkachuk. Try watching more than Leafs games for a change. Tkachuk makes a much bigger impact on the game than does Nylander. HAMONIC would be the core piece going back to Toronto in any potential Nylander trade. Not Tkachuk!
I also thought of this,but my reasoning was based on the Marner /Tkachuk success in junior. Maybe they would be good together again. That said ,I feel Willy is the better over-all player,different skill set,but better.Tkachuk for Nylander
(Willy a bit better, Tkachuk a bit cheaper)
Tkachuk - Matthews - Kapanen
Marleau - - Tavares - - - Marner
Johnsson - - - Kadri - - - Hyman
Gaudreau - Monahan - Nylander
Neal - - - Backlund - - - Lindholm
Bennett - - - Jankowski - - - Frolik
If you ignore that fact the Flames won't say yes to such a deal.I also thought of this,but my reasoning was based on the Marner /Tkachuk success in junior. Maybe they would be good together again. That said ,I feel Willy is the better over-all player,different skill set,but better.
Lulz
Why not? I mean if they need what Tkachuk brings then so be it,but Willy has a different tool set. Also more versatile. Not sure how many Leaf fans would be content with an even up trade.I would if Willy wants too much money or something,but it was mainly the Marner connection that the thought was born out of!If you ignore that fact the Flames won't say yes to such a deal.
There's 7 "defense to Toronto" threads on the 1st page of the trade forum, it's a good thing you're here with this revelation or we may never have realized thatHamonic is exactly what the Leafs need. A right shot, top-4 stay-at-home D. In fact, the Leafs tried to acquire him from the Islanders before losing out to the Flames. Offence is not your problem, defence is. When will Leafs fans realize that?