Forgive my noobish question, but could you guys compare Veleno to any other guys that scored at the same level, at the same age, playing in the Q that made it to the NHL?
Also, where do you think he would be drafted if NHL GMs got a do-over knowing what they know now?
The tough part with this is the evolution of Veleno is not something that you see all that frequently. He went from 1.23 points per game (0.34 goals per game) in his draft year, to now producing 1.92 points per game (0.78 goals per game). Oddly enough, Mantha had a massive spike from his D to D+1 year going from 1.33 (0.75) to 2.11 (1.00) playing in the Q, but his play style is obviously quite different from Veleno's. There is also Morgan Frost in the Philly organization who was drafted in 2017 at #27 after putting up 0.93 (0.30). He then went on to put up 1.67 (0.63) the following year. He is playing in the OHL right now.
But there a plenty of player's who have scored like Veleno currently is at some point; for example Claude Giroux in his D+1 year was producing at 1.78 (0.76) over 63 games. But at the same time, someone like Mantha who scored even more hasn't been able to gain traction in the NHL the way that others have. It's a mixed bag for sure.
In my opinion, you look at the knocks on Veleno and it was all about how much offense he would produce. Can he score on his own, are his assists relying on high level IQ, and not just on taking advantage of junior level players. His motor appears to be top-notch, he can skate, he has the intangible skills, he plays a well rounded game when it comes to responsibility; it was all going to come down to his offense. He is producing at very high levels right now, and while I'm sure there is still doubt, I'd be willing to bet he finds himself in the discussion starting around 10 plus or minus a few picks, and would be gone by 15. Centers who went ahead of him, Kotkaniemi (3), Hayton (5), Dellandrea (13), Foudy (18), O'Brien (19), Kupari (20), Lundestrom (23). There's no way Dallas would be taking Dellandrea over Veleno right now.
Edit: But what Shaman said is absolutely correct. The development of other players drafted will drastically impact a re-draft. My points are based exclusively on if there was a re-draft that happened today.