It's definitely the seat design that's the loge issue. The backs of the seat are higher, and there's some curve to them, with the seat in front of you bulging out in the center. Depending on how staggered your seat is with respect to the seat in front of you, it could either force you to (wo)manspread if your seat is directly behind the seat in front so the peak is at your crotch, or it could force you to sit with your knees squished in the center if you're exactly halfway between two seats in front, meaning you've got a peak to your left and a peak to your right. Let's just say that when I sat in the loge for the first preseason game, I took one of the now-famous "OMG Garden legroom" meme pictures even before it became trendy.
I haven't really spent much time in the loge, but I assume the number of rows is the same. They have reconfigured a little bit of the entrys for some of the loge sections - for some of the central ones you now step UP into some of the entryways from the concourse, and start at row 18. Before, the vomitorium entered at row 15, and you had to turn back and step up to go up a few rows. That shouldn't be the driving force of the legroom issue - it's the seat.
Not really buying the contractor issue yet, especially with the balcony seats. Maybe they installed the seats at a bad angle in the loge. That's about the only "contractor error" issue that there could be - and, FFS, shouldn't the Garden have done a once-over on the seats once they were installed? I had to have my A/C fixed, and the dude didn't leave until I felt the fan running cold air.
I'm just thankful the media took to this story last week. I told my STH guy at renewal time that it was awful to get an 8% increase in price when the seat size would likely decline during renovations. Obviously, he couldn't (and didn't) respond to my concern about seat size at the time, which was February or March...but the fact that some idiot like me could see the renovation problems on paper without even looking at a chair should have been a red flag to someone at the Garden.