Watching any player's highlights will paint them in a good light. Battler i think is a word that sums up Pelletier pretty well. He pursues the puck vehemently, never stops moving his feet and is first on the forecheck every time without fail. When you play that often and are one of your team's main offensive threats you're bound to have some impressive plays, but in the case of Pelletier, his setups are rarely impressive in terms of their creativity. It's generally the smart, safe play- keep the puck moving around the perimeter, maintain possession approach that he plays- which isn't a bad thing, but it's not the sign of a first line talent.
I also find when watching Pelletier that he lacks an elite skill. Shot? It's decent. Skating? Above average, but will never be a skill he can rely upon to put him in a top class. His hockey IQ is impeccable, but I believe it lacks a creative element.
There's really nothing that puts Pelletier over the top for me. An OK shot, pretty good skating, smart defensive and instinctual player, but without the vision necessary for that attribute to truly make him a star, and well those are really the big three. It all falls under the good but not great category to me.