Here’s my take, similar to the Hamonic trade last year the Sens look to acquire short term contracts as it isn’t easy luring free agents to Ottawa. Myers makes a ton of sense as he only has one year left, he’s slated to make $6 million signing bonus or not. Zaitzev makes $4.5 and is probably considered a worse asset as Ottawa would probably have to add to make things even out.
Zub is a pending UFA and is a piece Vancouver would covet to play with Hughes. Here is a deal I see playing out.
Van: Zub + Zaitzev
Ott: Myers + Hoglander + Rathbone
I can see Dermott inserted instead of Rathbone but I consider Rathbone a better and cheaper asset. The cost of dumping Zaitzev is more expensive than fans would like to admit and getting a Dman that will probably play top 4 in a deal is a huge upgrade for someone playing in the AHL. Basically they are getting Myers for 1.5 on a 1 year contract to replace Zub, if he plays well I’m sure he resigns. (Math was added onto the $4.5 Zaitzev contract, not Zub)
This makes sense if you're a Vancouver fan. No sense from the Ottawa side though - Rathbone and Hoglander are not needs at all and the subtraction of Zub is just a no.
Ottawa's biggest issue is that their defence looks like this:
Incredible - Good
Incredible - Below average
Average - Below average
Incredible: Chabot, Sanderson
Good: Zub
Average: Holden, Hamonic, JBD (provided they're only on the bottom pair)
Below average: Brannstrom, Thomson, Zaitsev, Larsson, Heatherington (as well as the previously mentioned Holden, Hamonic, JBD if they are forced to play up in the lineup)
Any deal needs to bring in another average guy at a minimum on the right side while keeping the good one. It's why Zub in
any deal makes zero sense because the second he's gone that right side becomes below average at best all the way down. We fully expect a Zub contract to be announced at some point to the tune of 5-6M x 6-8 years.
Ideally a deal with anyone results in the subtraction of a below average guy and the addition of an average guy (or better). The result of this
might allow one of our below average guys to be an average guy on the bottom pair. Dorion would be hoping Myers could be average in Ottawa on the middle pairing and that one of our existing guys could stabilize playing the same role every night on the bottom pair. Then we'd have:
Incredible - Good
Incredible - Average
Average - Average
It's still not ideal but they gotta do something.