He was our 2nd leading goal scorer in both the regular season and the playoffs, a team that won the Presidents trophy and went to the ECF, so that's probably not completely accurate.
His reputation as a playoff star is a tad hyperbolic. 31 points in 60 games is decent, not great, but it is besides the point.
The point is that someone making millions has no excuse for not skating hard on every shift. If he's not scoring, he should at least be a physical presence. Every 4th game is not good enough.