I'm kinda neutral on it so far (I'm about 50 pages in). Basically Will starts by linking modern Conservatism to the philosophy of Founding Fathers.. individual, innate natural rights etc. Nothing really new or especially insightful (so far). But I'll see.
I find that both the Left & Right basically agree on the legitimacy of natural rights, that's not the philosophic divide. I think political divide between modern Conservatives vs Progressives comes down to a basic (gut, not intellectual) question. Do u believe life/society was better in previous generations & should be conserved, or was society worse, & progressivism is required to fix our ancestors' flaws. And some of our response to this question is just our innate individual personality/hard wiring. We ultimately can't help if we're Conservative or Leftist (?) It's a relatively (& necessary) balance (people of tradition vs people of change) baked in to the human condition..