Transfer: 2019 Winter Transfer Rumors and Discussion Part II

Status
Not open for further replies.

bluesfan94

Registered User
Jan 7, 2008
31,019
8,231
St. Louis
Not when you gave you word TWICE. And retracted it between the two.
Without signing something, a promise in negotiations doesn't mean much. Now maybe if PSG had acted in reasonable reliance on it, it would mean something, but they didn't. Because they know how the game is played, too.

Keep this discussion to transfer dealings. Do not bring politics or any other agendas into this. Take any further issues with PSG and the De Jong transfer to pm.
Sorry just saw this. I think my post is general enough to transfer negotiations as a whole to be okay (and not political), but if not, I understand.
 

YNWA14

Onbreekbaar
Dec 29, 2010
34,543
2,560
Apparently Liverpool are in on Bergwijn. Very into this.

Wouldn't mind seeing Liverpool in on Nkunku. He seems talented, versatile and athletic...think Klopp could work well with him.

Also happy for de Jong to go to Barcelona. Hopefully de Ligt follows him. It all seems a bit blown out of proportion...where did he ever 'give his word' that he would sign for anyone?
 

S E P H

Cloud IX
Mar 5, 2010
30,934
16,407
Toruń, PL
Is nkunku good fit for arsenal @Evilo as Ramsey replacement
Can't speak for Evilo, but in my opinion he is definitely not as good as Ramsey going forward (generating offence out of nothing). However, I suggest that he's better on the defensive side of things and is a much better overall BxB guy. Again, picture a smarter version of Guendouzi.
 

Live in the Now

Registered User
Dec 17, 2005
53,164
7,582
LA
The media needs to stop linking us to this guy. His stats are awful.



Yeah but he's definitely not awful. He plays with garbage and that's why his stats are what they are.

Dortmund should aim higher I agree, but he should be playing for a team below the level of the very top teams.
 

les Habs

Registered User
Sep 21, 2005
22,239
3,967
Wisconsin
Some thoughts, observations and things of note on the De Jong transfer:

  • The fee isn't anything to sneeze at, but all things considered I don't think it's that bad. If he stays for say ten years and the market appreciates as it has historically then the fee won't seem bad at all in the future.
  • De Jong's wages put him in the "third tier" of Barça players. I'm fine with that considering his peers on this tier.
  • I'm very excited about this signing. I suspect he'll play CM, but I love his versatility. Hopefully he proves to be a creative force in midfield. I think he and Arthur will complement each other and between the two of them they'll very press resistant.
  • Sounds like the club made a really good pitch to De Jong last week and laid out what Barça had to offer compared to the competition. Bartomeu personally got involved and was part of the delegation that went to Holland.
  • Overmars: "I'm glad he signed for Barça. We are two clubs that are united by our history and our style of play."
  • The De Jong deal was finalized 30 years to the day the club signed Koeman.
  • De Jong has said it's a dream to get this move. Even his girlfriend said as much on Instagram when she recalled a trip they took to the Camp Nou a few years ago.
  • Too bad Cruyff isn't still around. Would love to hear his thoughts on the deal, though I suspect I'd have to read between the lines a bit.

The club has a lot of dead wood offload and I want to see a lot of homegrown players in the squad next season, but now I want them to go and get De Ligt.

KPB is pretty funny , you have to admit.

I certainly liked the days when La Masia was pumping out 1st team players instead of signing the Paulinho's , Andre Gomes, Arda Turan's of the world , but perhaps I'm a bit of a purist.

I think I read somewhere that in 2016-17 the 1st team had more La Masia products than Barcelona B , which is pretty baffling. That shouldn't even be possible.

Just hasn't been the same since Pep and Laporta , but it's not my club.

Seems it all started going downhill once Sandro Rosell got elected despite the 1st team success. I felt they lost their identity a little bit , and it's continued down that path a little more each season since.

I'm sure people will disagree.

They still are and have been pumping out first team players. As you know, plenty were sold. To blame Rosell and the board alone isn't accurate and rather lazy though. Thiago left after he didn't play enough under Vilanova. Bartra left after he didn't play enough under Lucho. And don't forget the players here. Thiago should have played more sure, but it should have been painfully obvious to him that it was just a matter of time. Bartra had to move for the good of his career at the time.

We're probably on the same page though. Were it down to me Thiago, Bartra, Grimaldo and Deulofeu would have never left. I also wouldn't have bought Paulinho, Gomes and especially Turan. Actually it's kind of funny because this is my criticism of Roma to a degree.

@les Habs You're right buddy, the Denis Suarez to Arsenal is dead since Barca wanted a 20 million buy-out clause after his loan and Arsenal wasn't having none of that. We could go back in for him during Summer, but Barca being super stingy AF for a second rate player.

Which position do they plan on playing him? CB or is he a successor to Busquets?

I'd say in this market that the quoted price for Denis is fair market value. Maybe if you take into account his contract length you might say otherwise, but I don't think there's a big difference.

Frenkie mentioned that Barca couldn’t guarentee him a starting spot. Management also told him to focus on developing more into a #7 or #8, with Busquets ofcourse being a lock as the #6.

Frenkie will have to duke it out with Arthur, Rakitic, Coutinho, Vidal, Puig and likely Rabiot. That’s quit the competition, but I am hoping he and Arthur become the regulars.

Yeah, I don't think the intention, at least initially, was ever to play him as an 8. I think he'll play the Iniesta role.

I think he'll get good minutes. At least one player will go, but it could also be more than one. I'd even consider letting three players go. Also though, Rabiot isn't confirmed and one of the Barcelona papers just reported today that it might not happen.

On a side note, I'd like to see more players move in the opposite direction. One guy that comes to mind is Samper. I'd prefer he got a chance with us, but never will. I think he'd slot into Ajax's midfield nicely, but you'd need a more steely defensive-minded midfielder there as well.

Rakitic is a goner. Vidal soon hopefully too

I'm guessing Rakitic goes as well, but I don't think Rakitic and Vidal both go. If we kept one I'd keep Rakitic.

I think Coutinho could be sold too depending on how the rest of the season plays out for him. His camp apparently made some rumblings and the reply was apparently "put your head down and work".

The problem with say losing Rakitic, Vidal and Coutinho is that the midfielders left after Busquets are young and inexperienced. I think the quality is there, but experience is important. Don't get me wrong, they will have experience, but only so much of it and only at a certain level.

So after giving his word to PSG, then not answering the phone while agreeing with Barca, then meeting with his PSG officials again, giving his word again for a 8M€ contract + bonuses, De Jong signed a 10M€ contract with Barca.

As I said, he's definitely from Amsterdam :D

There was clearly a saga there, but I'd love to see your source for this narrative.

I'm also curious how he "broke a promise". He might have verbally agreed a deal, which apparently he did with Barça while back. However he also might have changed his mind. There's nothing wrong with that in the absence of a contractual agreement. I once accepted a job offer only for my boss' boss to immediately have his assistant call me to tell me he was coming up the next day to see me. He convinced me not to leave the company and offered me money I didn't ask for. In the end I stayed and did not take the job I said I would. I handled it professionally by calling the person who made me the offer and apologizing for the situation and telling them I appreciated their time and their offer. If I could go back I'd have handled it slightly differently, but while I made a mistake I don't think it was that bad. I didn't expect my company to make such a move to keep me and perhaps De Jong didn't think Barcelona would make another push to sign him.

Keep this discussion to transfer dealings. Do not bring politics or any other agendas into this. Take any further issues with PSG and the De Jong transfer to pm.

...
 
  • Like
Reactions: Ajacied

robertmac43

Forever 43!
Mar 31, 2015
23,415
15,535
I would be very curious to see Zaha playing outside of the prem with talent around him. 50 Million seems about right for him considering today's market and he still has some miles ahead of him.
 

YNWA14

Onbreekbaar
Dec 29, 2010
34,543
2,560
Tell me why Bergwijn is better than Lozano. That being said I am all for Bergwijn
He's better with the ball at his feet, he's better in possession, he's more dynamic and versatile. I would also say he has a better work-rate. He's also 2 years younger, and despite the stats has been outperforming him on the same team. His pedigree is great too; golden ball at the u17 Euros playing for the Netherlands, has always performed well there and has always been considered one of the brightest talents in Holland (along with Nouri). Actually @Ajacied and I spoke about that a few times in our Dutch talent rankings.

All we need to do is bring in Koulibaly in the summer with Bergwijn and Werner and we're set.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Ajacied

bleedblue1223

Registered User
Jan 21, 2011
51,863
14,822
I like Zaha, he'd be a good get. I wouldn't mind Chelsea getting him as a 3rd/4th winger to help fill the home-grown quota. The worry with those players though is will they increase production on a better club or is there production somewhat high because they are the main player on a lower club.
 

JeffreyLFC

Registered User
Sep 29, 2017
10,184
7,296
I like Zaha, he'd be a good get. I wouldn't mind Chelsea getting him as a 3rd/4th winger to help fill the home-grown quota. The worry with those players though is will they increase production on a better club or is there production somewhat high because they are the main player on a lower club.
In the case of Zaha. He likes to play by himself a lot. He knows he is the man at Crystal Palace. That being said he is one of the best dribbler in the world and amazing at 1v1. He could become super sub for a top club.
 

bleedblue1223

Registered User
Jan 21, 2011
51,863
14,822
In the case of Zaha. He likes to play by himself a lot. He knows he is the man at Crystal Palace. That being said he is one of the best dribbler in the world and amazing at 1v1. He could become super sub for a top club.
Right. I could see him not fitting in with a club because not being able to play a team possession game. He has great speed and dribbling ability, so he can be deadly on the counter. Would've been perfect at Chelsea in the Mourinho or especially in the Conte days when it was counter heavy and the forwards were sheltered from defensive work.

Crystal would get more from a top English club looking to fill the HG quota IMO.
 

Jersey Fresh

Video Et Taceo
Feb 23, 2004
26,224
9,167
T.A.
Uruguayan Andy Carroll
Can't say that thought didn't cross my mind watching him move, but figured I should give him some benefit of the doubt with the price being talked about.

Seems really strange they'd target someone with that skillset too because that's just not how the team has played this season. They need someone mobile running ahead of Anderson to pick out.
 

Gecklund

Registered User
Jul 17, 2012
25,258
11,836
California
He's better with the ball at his feet, he's better in possession, he's more dynamic and versatile. I would also say he has a better work-rate. He's also 2 years younger, and despite the stats has been outperforming him on the same team. His pedigree is great too; golden ball at the u17 Euros playing for the Netherlands, has always performed well there and has always been considered one of the brightest talents in Holland (along with Nouri). Actually @Ajacied and I spoke about that a few times in our Dutch talent rankings.

All we need to do is bring in Koulibaly in the summer with Bergwijn and Werner and we're set.
All we need to do is break the world record for a CB again, and spend another 100M at least and we will be all set. :laugh: Not meaning any disrespect but I just found the last part funny.
 

StevenF1919

Registered User
Oct 9, 2017
4,312
5,234
Edmonton
He's better with the ball at his feet, he's better in possession, he's more dynamic and versatile. I would also say he has a better work-rate. He's also 2 years younger, and despite the stats has been outperforming him on the same team. His pedigree is great too; golden ball at the u17 Euros playing for the Netherlands, has always performed well there and has always been considered one of the brightest talents in Holland (along with Nouri). Actually @Ajacied and I spoke about that a few times in our Dutch talent rankings.

All we need to do is bring in Koulibaly in the summer with Bergwijn and Werner and we're set.
You can't afford Koulibaly.
 

StevenF1919

Registered User
Oct 9, 2017
4,312
5,234
Edmonton
It was tongue in cheek. ;)

Liverpool certainly could, if they wanted to.
Don't think they'd be able to spend $150M on another CB after buying Van Dijk. Koulibaly and Van Dijk would be one of the best, if not the best, CB pairings of the past 10 years though.
 

YNWA14

Onbreekbaar
Dec 29, 2010
34,543
2,560
Don't think they'd be able to spend $150M on another CB after buying Van Dijk. Koulibaly and Van Dijk would be one of the best, if not the best, CB pairings of the past 10 years though.
They've got a lot of money. A lot of their transfers have been fueled by shrewd and profitable sales. They could easily shell out $150m in a window now that they're practically guaranteed top 4 and have been doing well in the CL (unless I'm misunderstanding their financial situation, which is possible).

But again I don't think it's likely with who they already have, Joe Gomez's emergence and because they did just spend a bunch on a keeper and defender (as well as midfielders). I wouldn't be overly shocked if it did happen though.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Ad

Upcoming events

Ad

Ad