I don't think it is, no. That's what scouts do when they draft these young players. That's... Hell, it's what so many come here specifically to do. Do you never make predictions? When a pick is made, you don't imagine where their place in the lineup could eventually be if progress goes as hoped?
And besides, I think what TVT was getting at is that he wasn't concerned with Senyshyn being a defensive stalwart like so many insist. They drafted him to hopefully drive the bet and score goals... Not wrestle a Selke from Patrice Bergeron.
And that's fair. I think too many people here have been brainwashed by the last coaching regime that everyone needs to be a Selke caliber player just to get a shift or two. I think that belief was a big reason for the team's downturn over the last few years.
As for the rest, no. I don't make predictions, generally speaking. I think projections are relatively worthless and oftentimes people only project the positives or negatives based on how they view a player, so by default, they're biased. In terms of when a pick is made, I don't do what you do at all, Scott. It's so far out from when that guy is going to impact the NHL roster, if at all, so why bother? When a pick is made, I typically just hope the guy turns into something that can contribute in some fashion at the NHL level. Regardless of his junior pedigree or college resume.
One of my favorite projections from the last few years or so where when so many HF experts here were projecting Matt Fraser to step in and score a bunch of goals because of what he did in the AHL. I pointed out back then that AHL goal scoring doesn't translate to NHL goal scoring, and that went over like a fart in church. You could say the same thing here about Chiller. He was the fastest skater and had the hardest shot in the NHL in the skills competition. So people automatically started talking about how that skill would translate. Instead, the guy never developed and now he's gone.
So I get that what I may be saying may be taken as a downer, but seriously. Let's see what the kid can do and what his game looks like before penciling him in as a legitimate scoring RW. It's completely unfair to set so lofty a ceiling for a guy who isn't likely to even make this team next year. And even if he does, let's let the guy develop his game and learn how to play before suggesting he's going to be a 20+ goal scorer.