Trade Ideas Discussion Thread

[Old Guy]

I don't want Gavrikov to sign a pro contract this season. If he does, I think the CBJ would have to use a protection spot on him (this assumes a lot - but I would rather not have to worry about it, than make some Clarkson/Karlsson/Draft pick type deal).

 

[JohnnyJacket13]

Coyle
Dzingel
Anisimov
Compher
Duchene
Prout
Tarasenko
O'Reilly

Obviously all different levels of player, position, contract status, trade value/price and most importantly, availability.

One of these things is not like the other. One of these things doesn’t belong.

 

[thebus88]

I don't want Gavrikov to sign a pro contract this season. If he does, I think the CBJ would have to use a protection spot on him (this assumes a lot - but I would rather not have to worry about it, than make some Clarkson/Karlsson/Draft pick type deal).

Just give Ryan Murray a NMC and...… problem solved.

Or do we do that AND go 4 and 4?

Or is our defense too good at that point that we are better off trading a guy beforehand?

Jones, Murray, Werenski, Gavrikov, Nutivaara

At what point does or would our #4-5 D be worth more to another team and the return (offense?) be worth more to the CBJ, than what they could do for us in a #4-5 role?

 

[thebus88]

One of these things is not like the other. One of these things doesn’t belong.

Both Duchene and Dzingel are in the Eastern Conf and UFA's after this year.....

 

[CBJWerenski8]

I don't want Gavrikov to sign a pro contract this season. If he does, I think the CBJ would have to use a protection spot on him (this assumes a lot - but I would rather not have to worry about it, than make some Clarkson/Karlsson/Draft pick type deal).

I believe this is correct.

 

[JohnnyJacket13]

Both Duchene and Dzingel are in the Eastern Conf and UFA's after this year.....

I was referring to the AHL defenseman who skates like a beer league player and has the hockey IQ of a mini-mite that you listed in your otherwise ok list of targets.

 

[Theo Von]

Jackets could really use a goal scorer

 

[MoeBartoli]

Jackets could really use a goal scorer

Nice play, but I'm not sold. Do you have any video of him checking?

 

[Theo Von]

Nice play, but I'm not sold. Do you have any video of him checking?

 

[thebus88]

Wennberg-Milano- Kukan- 2nd

Dadonov-3rd

 

[Flyers Faithful]

What would the ask be for Bjorkstrand and why do you think his game hasn’t quite translated to the nhl yet? He was a major goal scorer in juniors.

Additionally what would be the ask on Panarin? Is it still the consensus that he’ll be leaving in the offseason?

 

[WannabeFinn]

Riley Nash + pick + prospect for Duchene, cond. pick added in case of extension

Panarin-Dubois-Atkinson
Foligno-Duchene-Bjorkstrand
Jenner-Wennberg-Anderson
Hannikainen/Milano-Dubinsky-Duclair

Pls

 

[mikeyp24]

What would the ask be for Bjorkstrand and why do you think his game hasn’t quite translated to the nhl yet? He was a major goal scorer in juniors.

Additionally what would be the ask on Panarin? Is it still the consensus that he’ll be leaving in the offseason?

Ill only really touch on part with Bjorkstrand in that his playstyle isnt exactly what our team is so he would likely greatly succeed in another environment like Karlsson did and also the fact he is behind Atkinson and Anderson on the right side doesnt leave him in much of a scoring role or with playmakers.

 

[Theo Von]

Riley Nash + pick + prospect for Duchene, cond. pick added in case of extension

Panarin-Dubois-Atkinson
Foligno-Duchene-Bjorkstrand
Jenner-Wennberg-Anderson
Hannikainen/Milano-Dubinsky-Duclair

Pls

This is sincerely a mockery if you really think the Senators would entertain and package that includes Riley Nish as the center piece for Duchene (assuming your “pick”/“prospect” isn’t something too high of value).

Pierre Dorian might be a dunce but he’s not that ludacris.

 

[WannabeFinn]

This is sincerely a mockery if you really think the Senators would entertain and package that includes Riley Nish as the center piece for Duchene (assuming your “pick”/“prospect” isn’t something too high of value).

Pierre Dorian might be a dunce but he’s not that ludacris.

I feel insulted that you think I believe Nash has any value.. lol

He's just there for salary and position swap. The prospect and pick would be where all the value is, of course.

 

[Flyers Faithful]

Ill only really touch on part with Bjorkstrand in that his playstyle isnt exactly what our team is so he would likely greatly succeed in another environment like Karlsson did and also the fact he is behind Atkinson and Anderson on the right side doesnt leave him in much of a scoring role or with playmakers.

What would Columbus be looking to get for Bjorkstrand

 

[thebus88]

What would Columbus be looking to get for Bjorkstrand

Nothing.

It would be "selling low", and we "need" what Bjorkstrand has shown glimpses of what he can do.

It really is just a depth chart thing. Although a lot of that does have to do with him.

 

[LetsGOJackets!!]

if Columbus could get Vlad Tarasenko on a rental contract I would make that deal... St Louis might take some decent draft picks at this point

 

[mikeyp24]

What would Columbus be looking to get for Bjorkstrand

A C or 0laymaking LW both need to understand backcheck.an A prospect.

 

[Flyers Faithful]

A C or 0laymaking LW both need to understand backcheck.an A prospect.

What about something around Voracek?

Bjorkstrand + for Jake if Panarin doesn’t resign

 

[Theo Von]

What about something around Voracek?

Bjorkstrand + for Jake if Panarin doesn’t resign

I highly doubt Philly would entertain that.. I guess it depends on what the plus is.

 

[Flyers Faithful]

I highly doubt Philly would entertain that.. I guess it depends on what the plus is.

Hypothetically if Panarin tells the Jackets he won't be resigning and will be hitting the UFA market would you do in the offseason

Voracek and a 2019 3rd

For

Bjorkstrand UFA Rights to Panarin and 2019 1st

 

[grindline]

This is my list of forwards I would be happy to add next year through either trade or free agency *

Matt Duchene
Tyler Seguin
Mark Stone
Vladimir Tarasenko
Eric Staal


* I do not hold a position in the Jackets front office. List purely for illustrative purposes. Your mileage may vary.

 

[punk_o_holic]

Hypothetically if Panarin tells the Jackets he won't be resigning and will be hitting the UFA market would you do in the offseason

Voracek and a 2019 3rd

For

Bjorkstrand UFA Rights to Panarin and 2019 1st

No because the 2019 1st would be a deal breaker for me. If they lose Bobrovsky and have no replacement then they could be real bad. I don't trust Korpisalo to be a starter. Elvis Merzlikens is a question mark. Besides Bob, are there any decent Ufa goalies available?

 

[Cyclones Rock]

Just give Ryan Murray a NMC and...… problem solved.

Or do we do that AND go 4 and 4?

Or is our defense too good at that point that we are better off trading a guy beforehand?

Jones, Murray, Werenski, Gavrikov, Nutivaara

At what point does or would our #4-5 D be worth more to another team and the return (offense?) be worth more to the CBJ, than what they could do for us in a #4-5 role?

NMCs should be rarely given out. Murray doesn't even come remotely close to deserving one.