Hopefully he'll some cup games early on and Pep will improve his distribution. Was hoping he'd go out on loan again. Who knows, we'll see how it goes.
Hopefully Horvath leaves. I was pissed when Brugge brought in Mignolet when Horvath was more than capable as a starter.
I was hoping he'd go out on loan, as well, but realistically, Steffen would probably get 10-15 games per season, if not beat out Ederson. Ederson is prone to getting injured and prone to getting red cards. What happens if Pep leaves? Many suspect he'll leave after one more season. Ederson is a big favorite of Guardiola. Ederson might leave himself if Man City has a Champions League ban. Worst case scenario, Steffen is sold to some mid/lower table Premier League team in three years where he can start for five years, and serve as the US #1 through the 2026 World Cup. Best case scenario, he beats out Ederson within the next season or two and is the starter for one of the best teams in the world.
I think the upside with this type of decision is higher. Sure, he could probably be a starter at Schalke or Everton or somewhere like that for 6-8 years without his position being under threat, but this decision has more upside. The only worry would be his form for the National Team if he's not playing regularly. I don't remember if we've ever had a starting keeper who was a back up at their club. I'm pretty sure all our top keepers over the years, Howard, Friedel, Keller were starters pretty much their whole careers, maybe aside from a season here or there.
I'm not that high on Horvath. He's been really shaky since he moved from Norway. Even at Brugge when he wasn't playing that bad, he made everything look so difficult. I don't think he's anywhere near as talented as Steffen either. But it'll definitely help us out to even have like a lower-half of the table starter in Germany, England, Italy, Spain if Steffen is at Man City, and might not be playing that often. We need a Guzan-Howard dynamic here between Horvath and Steffen. There might be some important games where Horvath is needed.