I've always liked Stamkos' game but at the same time he's still a guy who never shows up in big games and that has heavily diminished what people think of him. Absolutely no ability to raise the game of others around him. When he was injured a winger did a better job of elevating his teammates than he did. And now, a young 22yr old centre is doing stuff Stamkos could never do (Ie. play 2 way, winning hockey and raise the game of others).
Stammer is a hell of a fantasy player, but nothing more than that.
I think this is a fair point. It's not like he's not producing in the playoffs, 22 goals and 51 points thru 66 career playoff games is solid production when there's less time and space and less powerplays normally. But he's had two game winning goals in the playoffs. Not a lot for a guy known to be a sniper and one of his team's key players. Last season's run was especially frustrating in that regard. He has put up the numbers (7 goals, 16 points in 17 games) but losing two elimination games with zero goals for in the ECF makes it easy to put the blame on him (and our other star players). He has yet to step up in the playoffs as his predecessors like Brad Richards, Vinny Lecavalier, Marty St. Louis or heck, even Tyler Johnson have done.
So overall I agree, stellar regular season stats and runs like the one he's currently on are satisfying and all but in the end all that matters is how he's playing in April and beyond. He has yet to find that extra gear. Still, his current performance gives us Lightning fans hope that he's found back to greatness and that he has finally overcame his past injuries. That's a tough task if you ask me. Most of us were sure he would continue to decline after his broken leg and blood clots, be a solid 2nd liner with 60-70 points at best.
As others have pointed out, last season he had a red hot start into the season (together with Kucherov) and finished over a point per game. But this time it's not a bunch of secondary assists bolstering his stats, he has a heavy impact on the outcome of games, a positive impact at that, on both ends of the ice. His two-way game has improved a lot, he's not just the trigger man anymore, he's creating plays, winning key faceoffs, taking shifts on the PK, he's doing everything and the best part is, these have all been weaknesses in his game or downright things he has never done before. Right now he excels in his new found role. He has become a way more complete player than we could have ever imagined.
Before his injuries he was pretty one dimensional - and terrific at that, to be sure: 156 goals over three consecute regular seasons, including a 60 goal season and the most even strength goals in a single season in a long time. But now he's a true centerman able to play in all situations and putting up meaningfull points and plenty of them on top. Great to see!