Here's the data if anyone wants to use it to support their position:
I'm not sure it was true than, since Binnington was in net almost non-stop from the time he got called up that year. Allen got most of his start while Binnington was in the AHL.
However, I think the issue with Allen always as been in between his ears. He's a good goalie technically and has a good frame. His time in Montreal and maturity that come with age have made him progress from a mental toughness standpoint in my opinion.
He's not a bad add for a cheap price, specially for a team like Carolina or Toronto dealing with ton of injuries and having green goalies in net. I'd let him go for a 3rd round pick, but seems like Hughes is hungrier than I am which is probably why he's still with the team right now.