And it’s not to say Holmgren didn’t do serious and avoidable damage to the team, but he also walked into an equally-morbid situation, if not worse: A flawed, garbage roster with basically two good young talents (Carter and Richards) and a guy no one expected to be a franchise player (Giroux).
That’s not close to true — Homer did not walk into “an equally morbid situation.”
Holmgren walked into a GREAT situation. Far, far better than he left it when fired.
True, he took over a team that would finish last in the league, but it was still a team that had been an East contender for years & was intentionally set up as beautifully as can be for an immediate turnaround.
True, perhaps pre-Homer they miscalculated a year early how ready Richards & Carter would be, & got killed by Forsberg playing only 40 games & the goaltending being an epic disaster. But they knew they were in for a mediocre season & had planned well to be able to reload in the off-season with loads of cap room to add to a young Richards, Carter, & Giroux.
Holmgren reaped the benefits of the good cap management & planning before him (something he would do the opposite of to the GM taking over for him later) by adding FAs Briere, Timonen, Hartnell, & Biron.
You aren’t going to inherit a better center situation than a 21 y/o Carter, 21 y/o Richards, & a 19 y/o Giroux in the system.
He also inherited a 22 y/o Pitkanen on D who was a recent 4th overall pick & loaded with value;
he inherited a 26 y/o 41 goal scoring Gagne;
a 24 y/o promising Umberger who had already scored 20 goals in the NHL;
AND Peter Forsberg, the most sought after trade deadline acquisition in years!
Oh, & he started with the #2 overall pick (JVR) also.
You’d be very hard pressed to take over a more fertile situation as NHL GM than Holmgren did.