Jtabo
Registered User
I didn't make a claim either way.
I provided comparative stats on Phaneuf and Suter and asked you to make a case to back up your claim of Suter being 10x better. I even let you off the hook and only asked that you make a case he is twice as good.
So go ahead.......show some evidence that Suter is twice as good as Phaneuf. It's a fairly simple request.
BTW....you didn't show any stats to back up the other silly claims either. Just sayin.
Suter is a great dman who has had the luxury of good and great partners. Phaneufis a great dman aswell who has had the luxury of inadequate partners since he came to Toronto. Case closed. If Phaneuf got to play with Weber and Brodin he would be regarded as potentially a top 5 dman. And really don't think anyone could have done better than Phaneuf in his situation last year. Maybe Chara, or Weber, but even then it would only be marginally better. Chara and Weber have had the luxury of good d partners as well.