Unbiased Fan
Registered User
- May 24, 2019
- 3,647
- 1,621
The only issue I see with this proposed situation is that we don’t lose any additional players. At the end of the day, we keep all of our defensemen and have the choice of either adding Heinola or Jiricek/Nemec. I think our defensive core looks a lot better with those guys than Heinola.
Also RHD is the rarer commodity, I don’t foresee us ever having a surplus in that so it’s always a benefit to have.
Like I said that’s exceptional value, but long term I think our 3LD will be a Holden type as opposed to a Heinola type. Way too good of a player that will command too much money to be playing on the third pair for extended commitment.
7th for Heinola + 14th still on the table if one of those RHD aren’t there?Appreciate the response and we are aligned in that we both prefer Jiricek/Nemec to Heinola + 14OA. I was hoping that adding a legit forward prospect in addition to Heinola may make it worth your while because I thought you were already pretty set on the right side. No deal to be made for the pick but in the event you guys drafted one of the RHD I'd be sniffing around JBD and Thomson to see if I can shake one of them loose.
I love this take. On one hand you are agreeing to a weegar + Reinhardt trade and on the other you say Nylander is hard pressed to get a top 10 pick. Weegar and Reinhardt were crap for Florida and I wouldnt trade Nylander alone for both.Could be something I could see Ottawa liking. Good chance Weegar re-signs with us too as he is from Ottawa. Reinhart isn't too expensive and has 2 years left.
Lets us run:
Tkachuk-Norris-Batherson
Formenton-Stutzle-Reinhart
Chabot-Zub
Sanderson-Weegar
Holden-Hamonic
Zaitsev
Which leads me to wonder why FLA would ever do it? Are they giving up on contention already? Reinhart seems like a guy you'd keep around.
0 chance anyone gives a top 10 pick for Muzzin and a late first. I think you may be in tough to even find a taker on Nylander for a top 10 pick after the playoffs he had.
Unfortunately no. Would only make sense for us if we moved up to grab a RHD. We'll get a similar player at 14 to a forward drafted at 7 IMO.7th for Heinola + 14th still on the table if one of those RHD aren’t there?
He just had 7 points in 7 Playoff games and 8 points in 7 playoff games last year. Yet he is not worth a top 10 pick?????0 chance anyone gives a top 10 pick for Muzzin and a late first. I think you may be in tough to even find a taker on Nylander for a top 10 pick after the playoffs he had.
Unfortunately you can't cure clueless. Nylander has been excellent for the Leafs as you've shown.He just had 7 points in 7 Playoff games and 8 points in 7 playoff games last year. Yet he is not worth a top 10 pick?????
for perspective Kevin Fiala had 3 points in 6 play off games this year and 2 points in 7 games last year. But he is worth 7th overall+ ?????
I get there are things about Nylander we all hate but he has been a point a game in the last 3 playoff series.
Pasta and foligno for 7th overall plus chabot colin white and next year 1st round pick unprotected.
I just wonder if the Sens would take a shot at a disgruntled Scheifele with that pick.
Petry has a NMC, and would never waive for Ottawa.Montreal offers Petry a first this year (CGY) and their 2nd (33rd)
Lundkvist is worth no more than a late 1st. He's an OK prospect that's not exactly done a ton to make you think he's a surefire top player, which you expect from a top 10 pick. Absurd to think that he's worth anything remotely close to a top 10 pick. He's 4 years removed from his draft and isn't particularly exceptional. He's worth about what he was drafted at - maybe slightly more because he's more of a sure thing.Could there be a connection with the Rangers?
Would someone like Lundkvist be a good start? He is one of the best NHL RD prospects in the entire league. He’s just blocked off by Fox, Trouba, and Schneider.
I would want to see the Rangers trade from a position of strength for a C like Savoie.
What else would the Rangers have to include to make a deal enticing for OTT?
Arizona <-- #7, White, Murray
Ottawa <-- 2022 3rd rd pick
Arizona get a top 10 pick, plus a couple of overpaid vets to help them reach the cap floor during their rebuild
Ottawa clear 11 million in cap space which they can put to better use
No thank you, if our experience with Brady has taught us anything, it would be that we would not like to negotiate with Matthew after a 40 goal 100 point season.Matthew Tkachuk for Jake Sanderson and 7th overall.
No thank you, if our experience with Brady has taught us anything, it would be that we would not like to negotiate with Matthew after a 40 goal 100 point season.
To be strong armed into spending north of 10 million (probably 11 to sign in Ottawa) dollars or having Chucky sit out unless he gets his two years that walks him to unrestricted free agency.I think that's a pretty fair offer on Calgarys part. We are taking the mystery box here in exchange for cap relief, which Ottawa has plenty of to unite the Tkachuks. You want help? There it is.
To be strong armed into spending north of 10 million (probably 11 to sign in Ottawa) dollars or having Chucky sit out unless he gets his two years that walks him to unrestricted free agency.
Yeah value is probably fair and I’ll go as far as to say even light for a 100 point player. Doesn’t work for us.
Edit: even worse, he’s one year away from RFA status
Then we can wait for him to exercise his right to sign his 1 year deal that will take him to UFA and sign him without spending a first and Sanderson if the odds are high he will sign here.Odds are he signs with his brother though, who is already locked up.
Then we can wait for him to exercise his right to sign his 1 year deal that will take him to UFA and sign him without spending a first and Sanderson if the odds are high he will sign here.
Doesn’t really address anything I say but feel free to take your run at him once his contract is up.We will take Brady if that's your worry.
Doesn’t really address anything I say but feel free to take your run at him once his contract is up.
You… you just said you’d take him, and I said once his contract is done?At that contract? Ha