Not really, considering that I just told you why this wasn't a favorable scenario. Just because the Devils didn't have any centers doesn't make Rasmussen any worse of a commodity.
Your argument is also backed by nothing, because only 1 full season has been played since both players were drafted. My prediction, not "argument", is based on player profiles. If you haven't seen Rasmussen play, and just make a blank judgement on players by draft position and stat-watching, then you're not capable of making an informed decision. I'm making an informed opinion that I suspect both players will provide equal/similar value to both teams throughout their careers. If you want to be a homer, or ignorant, about it then that's your prerogative.