Mitch Marner vs Brock Boeser

[Hugh Mungus]

Your last 31 of 32 posts have been leaf bashes. You don’t have any credibility with anything leaf related.

Make your account private at least. It’s way too easy to see your agenda.

Apart from the joke at the end, I don't think there's anything wrong with what I said really.

Also nice to see how much you care about someone's posts on a hockey forum on the internet.

But is it really that serious though?

 

[Brock Radunske]

Just get out of here, Boeser played, what, 65 games?He surely would have hit 30 and perhaps maybe scored more then your 'generational' playoff ghost did in his rookie season.

7 pts in 13 games as a rookie/sophomore #1C in the playoffs is a ghost?
What about McDavid's 9 pts in 13 games? Is he a ghost, too?

It's easy for you to spout off about stuff like this considering Boeser won't see a playoff game until his prime...

 

[Voodoo Child]

Boeser and Marner are on similar tiers as top young players (behind a top five of McDavid, Matthews, Eichel, Mack and Laine) with guys like Barzal, Pastrnak, Rantanen, Hischier, Draisaitl and the like.

Nothing the Canucks have, have ever had or will ever have is worth Matthews.

 

[Randy Randerson]

Totally agree. Skill players, especially young guys, I think people assume they're crap defensively until proven otherwise. I also think Marner's babyface makes people assume he's tiny. He looks like he's everyone's shy nephew.

he does look like a little kid and is still around 175lbs, but I think it's often forgotten that he's 6' tall. Also think that this year goes a long way to proving how good he is without the puck, was a huge plus defensive player but I guess results usually precede reputation by a bit

 

[Namikaze Minato]

Proof you don't watch Boeser. Sorry the universe doesn't revolve around your playoff chokers. Boeser would be better then anyone outside of Matthews. SO take off those blue tinted glasses and give your delusional head a shake.

Right and I’m sure you rush home to watch the leafs? Boeser didn’t start the season playing on your basement dwelling, steamy pile of shit team he definitely wouldn’t have played for the leafs.

Would have been a fantastic edition to the marlies though.

 

[X66]

Imagine these two as line-mates.

 

[Atomos2]

Proof you don't watch Boeser. Sorry the universe doesn't revolve around your playoff chokers. Boeser would be better then anyone outside of Matthews. SO take off those blue tinted glasses and give your delusional head a shake.

Rather be playoff chokers than regular season chokers. Can't even get a seat at the table. Way to go Boeser

 

[Mess]

Marner is the better playmaker and Boeser is the better sniper and goal scorer.

 

[BlueBaron]

Boeser is a good young player any team would be lucky to have. If we are talking about just goals he wins this hands down. However in terms of offensive ceiling I suspect Marner will be a better producer over all.

 

[rent free]

As opposed to the Leafs' illustrious playoff record over the past 40 years ...

Can't win unless there's 6 teams and has access to all the best english-speaking talent in the league and, even then, still outdone by Montreal.

how do the leafs have" access to all the best english-speaking talent in the league"?

 

[The Moose is Loose]

I hate siding with the brutal leafs homers (cough cough IPS).

But id take Marner

 

[Love]

Nothing the Canucks have, have ever had or will ever have is worth Matthews.

Damn why are you so mad

 

[Byron Bitz]

Boeserd shot is money but Marner can do so many different things out there and always drives the offense on his line so il go with Marner.

 

[Tad Mikowsky]

Right and I’m sure you rush home to watch the leafs? Boeser didn’t start the season playing on your basement dwelling, steamy pile of **** team he definitely wouldn’t have played for the leafs.

Would have been a fantastic edition to the marlies though.

You’re delusional thinking Boeser wouldn’t have played on the Leafs this season. Yikes.

 

[nowhereman]

Right and I’m sure you rush home to watch the leafs? Boeser didn’t start the season playing on your basement dwelling, steamy pile of **** team he definitely wouldn’t have played for the leafs.

Would have been a fantastic edition to the marlies though.

Boeser is better than every player on the Leafs with the exception of Matthews. You have no idea what you're talking about. But nice try, Leafs homer. You're in the running for stupidest post of the week!

But it's funny to see how quickly you and your like have forgotten that your team was the laughing stock of the NHL for the last decade. Perhaps you shouldn't be throwing stones inside that glass house of yours, until the Leafs actually accomplish something more than just making the playoffs.

Nothing the Canucks have, have ever had or will ever have is worth Matthews.

Bure and the Sedins might have something to say about that. Matthews is barely a PPG player and has disappointed in the playoffs so far. Obviously, he's very young and has time to get there but this isn't a Crosby/OV/McDavid-level player we're talking about here. He has A LOT to prove, before you start comparing him against HHOFers like Bure and H. Sedin.

 

[Namikaze Minato]

You’re delusional thinking Boeser wouldn’t have played on the Leafs this season. Yikes.

he didn't even make the canucks opening roster and Toronto/ Babs is swimming in winger depth. Nobody expected boeser to be as good as he was in the NHL, he wouldn't have had the same chance with the leafs.

Boeser is better than every player on the Leafs with the exception of Matthews. You have no idea what you're talking about. But nice try, Leafs homer. You're in the running for stupidest post of the week!

But it's funny to see how quickly you and your like have forgotten that your team was the laughing stock of the NHL for the last decade. Perhaps you shouldn't be throwing stones inside that glass house of yours, until the Leafs actually accomplish something more than just making the playoffs.


Bure and the Sedins might have something to say about that. Matthews is barely a PPG player and has disappointed in the playoffs so far. Obviously, he's very young and has time to get there but this isn't a Crosby/OV/McDavid-level player we're talking about here. He has A LOT to prove, before you start comparing him against HHOFers like Bure and H. Sedin.

better than everyone except Matthews while being compared to marner who's less important than Rielly, right.

We remember those years and how insufferable canucks fans were when they were a good team, just because your shit now doesn't mean we don't remember when you were (and somehow still are) the arrogant ones.

Half the canucks fans still seem to think they can trade scrubs like gudbranson and Sutter for the second overall pick, or that Tanev is more valuable than Hamilton when he was traded. If anyone needs a reality check its canucks fans. At least oiler and habs fans see the horrible state of their franchises, you guys act like signing a new eriksson deal will turn you around because you have 2 good prospects.

 

[CantLoseWithMatthews]

You’re delusional thinking Boeser wouldn’t have played on the Leafs this season. Yikes.

What do you mean? At the start of the year he wasn't a ~30 goal NHLer. He didn't even crack the Canucks roster at first, and the Leafs have way stronger RW depth. he'd have had to play in our bottom 6, and Babcock might not have loved that idea. That doesn't mean Boeser isn't an extremely talented player, but circumstances do point to the possibility that he might not have even played for the Leafs

 

[rent free]

where is this nonsense that boeser didn't make the canucks roster at first coming from? his one game healthy scratch in the third game of the regular season?

Canucks Set 2017.18 Opening Night Roster

 

[Namikaze Minato]

where is this nonsense that boeser didn't make the canucks roster at first coming from? his one game healthy scratch in the third game of the regular season?

Canucks Set 2017.18 Opening Night Roster

Boeser exemplifying maturity despite scratch from Canucks lineup - Sportsnet.ca

He was healthy scratched on the canucks opening roster.

Brock Boeser Stats and News

First game was October 12th.

 

[LeafsNation75]

What do you mean? At the start of the year he wasn't a ~30 goal NHLer. He didn't even crack the Canucks roster at first, and the Leafs have way stronger RW depth. he'd have had to play in our bottom 6, and Babcock might not have loved that idea. That doesn't mean Boeser isn't an extremely talented player, but circumstances do point to the possibility that he might not have even played for the Leafs

When looking at the Leafs depth I can't see how Boesser would have started this season with the Leafs if he was on their roster. Someone like Kasperi Kapanen who had a very good 2017 playoffs didn't even make the Leafs opening night roster and started with Marlies in the AHL.

 

[Pyrophorus]

You’re delusional thinking Boeser wouldn’t have played on the Leafs this season. Yikes.

I agree with you. At worst he would've started with the Marlies, and would've been given sheltered minutes once on the big club.

 

[Connor McConnor]

Marner is a much more talented player than Boeser. It's like comparing Kane-light to a supped up Patches. One guy is good at everything offensive related (goal scoring will come) and the other guy excels at one area (scoring goals).

 

[Pyrophorus]

When looking at the Leafs depth I can't see how Boesser would have started this season with the Leafs if he was on their roster. Someone like Kasperi Kapanen who had a very good 2017 playoffs didn't even make the Leafs opening night roster and started with Marlies in the AHL.

Boeser has shown more than big game Kappy. Look all the people who have leap-frogged Leivo.
No doubt Boeser leap frogs him too.

 

[LeafsNation75]

Boeser has shown more than big game Kappy. Look all the people who have leap-frogged Leivo.
No doubt Boeser leap frogs him too.

So when looking at the Leafs opening night roster from this past season, who would Boeser have passed to start that night?

Toronto Maple Leafs - Winnipeg Jets - October 4th, 2017

 

[eviohh26]

All I've learnt from this thread is Boeser isn't good enough to play on the leafs. He would get sheltered minutes on the Marlies. Gotcha!