I think his critics and supporters have stayed pretty consistent. It's mostly a matter of who's more vocal at any given time.Can't believe anyone would choose Talbot over Kahkonen. Nuts.
Also it's hilarious to see all the love for Greenway. This board used to bag on him quite regularly.
He does seem to have taken a step this year and isn't running as hot-and-cold as last season. He'll move squarely into Jackpot territory if he can show he's the sort of player that turns it on in the playoffs.