Player Discussion Marc Staal
- Thread starter DieByTheShield
- Start date
- Status
Doctor King Schultz
Garian Maborik
Then maybe he shouldn't have played? I have a hard time believing Staal with a broken ankle > Matt Hunwick. It either means broken ankles are not a big deal or AV ****ed up.
Last edited by a moderator:
Absolute abomination on skates. Matt Hunwick would have faired better against staal's competition, the killorn-filppula-stamkos line cause dude can at least skate with those guys.
Staal skates in mud nowadays and falls over his own feet (one time leading directly to a goal off an oddman rush). He's just a cringeworthy player to watch, especially with the puck on his stick. He makes Girardi look like a PMD.
Injuries decimated his career. He was once a physically dominant legit top-pair guy, even showing some semblance of a 2WD when he had that season of ~30 ESP, and a few nice goals joining the rush/going coast-to-coast. He lost his hitting dimension which made him so dominant and fearful back in the day, and he has been reduced to using his cane to try and poke check everything that moves in front of him, leading to him getting beat a lot. If I am a top-6 forward, I am licking my chops to go up against Marc Staal nowadays.
See if you can trade the guy to a young a team that wants a top 4 defenseman to get rid of his contract. I'd rather have Danny over Staal anyway, he's a better defenseman at this point.
Staal skates in mud nowadays and falls over his own feet (one time leading directly to a goal off an oddman rush). He's just a cringeworthy player to watch, especially with the puck on his stick. He makes Girardi look like a PMD.
Injuries decimated his career. He was once a physically dominant legit top-pair guy, even showing some semblance of a 2WD when he had that season of ~30 ESP, and a few nice goals joining the rush/going coast-to-coast. He lost his hitting dimension which made him so dominant and fearful back in the day, and he has been reduced to using his cane to try and poke check everything that moves in front of him, leading to him getting beat a lot. If I am a top-6 forward, I am licking my chops to go up against Marc Staal nowadays.
See if you can trade the guy to a young a team that wants a top 4 defenseman to get rid of his contract. I'd rather have Danny over Staal anyway, he's a better defenseman at this point.
HFBS
Noted Troublemaker
- Jan 18, 2015
- 2,144
- 2,128
Does he really have a "broken ankle"? Is it broken in half? Is it in his locker? Broken ankle is too general a term. If his ankle was really "broken", he'd be in a cast. He's been this way too long for a mythical broken ankle to be the reason.
Granted, I haven't seen any official word yet on whether he was playing through a broken ankle...only rumors. But just wanted to point out what I thought was amusing reading through this thread:
Ryan McDonagh played through fractured foot (and understandably played pretty poorly doing so in game 7): "What a warrior. Proud of my captain."
Marc Staal may have played through a broken ankle: "What a loser. Absolute abomination on skates. Get this trash heap off my team."
--
Waiting to hear whether or not he actually had a broken ankle before passing judgment. Thought he wasn't terrible this postseason, but definitely a far cry from what I would have wanted from him. If he was playing on one leg, I kind of get why that might have been the case though...
Ryan McDonagh played through fractured foot (and understandably played pretty poorly doing so in game 7): "What a warrior. Proud of my captain."
Marc Staal may have played through a broken ankle: "What a loser. Absolute abomination on skates. Get this trash heap off my team."
--
Waiting to hear whether or not he actually had a broken ankle before passing judgment. Thought he wasn't terrible this postseason, but definitely a far cry from what I would have wanted from him. If he was playing on one leg, I kind of get why that might have been the case though...
haohmaru
boomshakalaka
FWIW, I don't see how playing a guy with a broken foot and another with a broken ankle is the better option than sliding Hunwick back in the lineup and giving him limited minutes and playing 4-5D.
Broadway Brad
Registered User
- Feb 26, 2012
- 290
- 35
Staal's new contract kicks in July 1 which allegedly includes NTC for 3 years and limited NTC for the following 3 years. Does anyone know what kind of trade protection (if any) his current contract offers? Depending on the current contract language, there may be a window between now and July 1 to move him. RB?
Rick Nash 61
The Best
It's obviously just a fracture. Maybe it was a small fracture or something idk but I fractured my ankle in 3 spots back in 2012 playing football and I can tell you there is no way any cortisone shot or ice could make it feel better, let alone play hockey haha. I was in a cast for 8 weeks.
His fracture probably wasn't as bad as my fracture but it is damn impressive that he was able to play at all. I'm guessing they gave him a cortisone shot more than one and basically froze the **** out of it before the games. Regardless, no way he could play at a high level with a fracture (unless it's a micro fracture or whatever).
Either way, I completely agree that healthy Staal needs to be better, and I wouldn't be opposed to trading him before the NTC kicks in on July 1st.
Like the Girardi contract, had a provision to kick in immediately. Unfortunately, no window.
https://twitter.com/Real_ESPNLeBrun/status/556102843477000192
(And not that it should come up, but Marc has a special NMC for the entire contract that pertains only to being put on waivers).
Last edited:
Parker
Registered User
The Lunatic Fridge
why is my name here?
He was good vs PIT. Don't know if he had his supposed broken ankle at that point but if he did that be some amazing **** if he stopped malkin with a broken ankle.
Ryan McDonut
Registered User
man i remember when staalsy was a top defenseman in the league. then his dumbass brother gave him a concussion. i dont think he'll ever get back to that level again sadly
UAGoalieGuy
Registered User
After a slow start, Staal played great for the rest of the regular season, shut down Malkin completely in the playoffs, and amazingly, while playing badly this last series, still somehow reduced Stamkos to an afterthought in five of seven games. The sky isn't falling with Marc Staal. His biggest offense is he's been here so long, he no longer has that new car smell.
Ail
Based and Rangerspilled.
Swept In Seven
Disciple of The Zook
- Apr 27, 2010
- 9,687
- 1
my sentiments exactly, he has just begun getting back to top form after the eye injury and I expect him to be more along the lines of old Marc next season.
Inferno
Registered User
nsvoyageurs
Registered User
New York Rangers @NYRangers 6 hours ago
#NYR Injury Update: Marc Staal had a bone chip removed from his ankle yesterday. He is expected to be fully recovered prior to training camp
#NYR Injury Update: Marc Staal had a bone chip removed from his ankle yesterday. He is expected to be fully recovered prior to training camp
Captain Monglobster
Registered User
- Nov 9, 2005
- 1,784
- 955
Had a hairline ankle fracture playing hockey in HS close to the joint. Dr said if it was a little bit closer would have had to have surgery. Not saying the fracture is in the same place, but forget about hockey I could barely walk and I didn't chip my ankle.
Guy gets no love around here because he doesn't play a sexy game. Marc Staal is best when you don't notice him. He'll be fine.
Guy gets no love around here because he doesn't play a sexy game. Marc Staal is best when you don't notice him. He'll be fine.
FLYLine27*
BUCH
Staal is as solid as they can come. Like others have said, because hes not "sexy" he gets no love.
So glad we locked him up long term, McD and him are going to anchor the blueline for the next half decade on the 1st and 2nd pairing respectfully.
So glad we locked him up long term, McD and him are going to anchor the blueline for the next half decade on the 1st and 2nd pairing respectfully.
- Status
