Justin Schultz should be kicking himself for going to Deadmonton.
Not really, he got a contract he wanted and still getting guaranteed ice-time(which he also wanted). Leafs didn't guarantee him time.
Just because Deadmonton isn't good right now, doesn't mean they can't or won't be in the future. They have a a great corps of young players to build around. Still missing a few pieces, but can only get better.
And DeKeyser should have the foresight to see that the Leafs are on the rise and the Wings are headed in the opposite direction. Their homegrown defensemen like Ericsson, Kindl and Smith haven't exactly been good...
He still has to crack the lineup. He also has to surpass 6-7 capable NHLers, a couple of more who can play, but are now in the AHL, plus, bypass a former #5 overall draft pick, a #58 overall pick, a #35 overall pick, and a #25 overall pick.
Each of those defenseman aren't really similar to the other, and each brings a different skill-set to the table.
Red Wings are still the Red Wings. They have a history of developing talent like Lidstrom, and Kronwall.
The Leafs have had just as many hits and misses as the Red Wings have at drafting and developing defenseman. You can go back to Jeff Ware, Carlo Coliacovo, or in more recent times Stralman, Doherty, and Kronwall.
His path to the NHL, at least from what I can tell is easier with Detroit than it is with Toronto.
I don't really see the salivating factor over DeKeyser is anyways. He put up alright numbers, but not exactly eye-popping ones like Schultz did. Scored a grand total of 12 goals over the course of the three seasons he played at WMU. Including 2 this NCAA season.