Again. Beaulieu will be protected or traded.
Of course.
We will see this summer. But i'm almost sure i'm right. Beaulieu will be protected and Benn wont be claimed. I will be very surprised if LV claim Benn.
Agreed. Worst case, we can offer a contract to Beaulieu that makes him less interesting to LV.
It's not an easy decision. Beaulieu is still young and produces more offensively. I love Benn but does not make long term sense. This expansion draft really sucks. I see it as 50/50 decision.
Beaulieu is 23 years old and can produce easily 30 points.
Benn is 30 years old and scored 20 points once.
Also Benn started to play in NHL at 25 years old.
I've "Benn" saying it for a while now, when it comes to the D, protect :
Weber
Petry
Benn
This will be beyond the easiest decision Bergevin will have to make.
If he does that it will be his worst decision as a GM.
Benn will most likely never reach 30 points and at 29 what you have is what you get. Once 20 points and that's it.
As for Beaulieu, at 23, it is 25 points in 65 games for now: a pace of 33 points...
Last year: 19 points in 64 games. A pace of 25 points.
For now, Markov and Weber are producing more for sure.
Petry is about the same as Beaulieu and that is the best season for Petry so far. Before that his best season was 2 goals and 25 points in 73 games.
Beaulieu has already done better.
Actually, who will be the best d-men at 29 years old: Petry now or Beaulieu in 6 years? Benn now or Beaulieu in 6 years?
He still does errors but he is learning and his defense is improving.
Slowly but improving.
I keep repeating: Beaulieu might score 40 points at 25-26 years old.
How many d-men scored 40 points last season? 26...
With Beaulieu, Weber and Markov getting 40 points we would be the only team besides Calgary to have three d-men with 40 points.
Beaulieu is on pace for 30 points right now.
How many d-men scored 30 points last season? 50
Besides Nsh, LAK, CGY, Tor and Stl, what team had 3 or more d-men with 30 points last year? None.
Ari, Bos, Chi, SJS, Mtl, Col, Dal, NYR, Wsh all had two d-men with 30 points.
Lets resume: Nsh had 4 d-men with 30 points till they traded Jones.
So basically 5 teams in NHL had 3 d-men with 30 points.
9 other teams in NHL had two d-men with 30 points.
That leaves 16 teams with one (or none) d-men with 30 points.
Just for reference: Sekera scored 30 points, Jones/Martinez/Campbell/Gardiner scored 31 points, Muzzin/Leddy scored 40 points. Parayko: 33 points, Pietro: 37 points. Shattenkirk will most likely get 7MX7 years with his 44 points last season.
One last comment: protecting Weber, Petry and Benn, who plays as LHD?
With Weber, Petry, Beaulieu, Markov and Sergachev we could have could have four or five d-men who could score 30 points.
BTW, so far this season, there are only 48 d-men who have 30 points and 57 (including Beaulieu) who have 25 points.
We are the only team in the league who has 4 d-men
with 25 points: Weber, Markov, Petry, Beaulieu. A few team have three and most teams have one or two.
Teams with one or two d-men with 25 points (bolded teams have only one):
Ana, Ari,
Bos,
Buf, Car, CBJ, Chi,
Col,
Dal, Det, Fla, Edm, Lak,
Njd, Nyi, Ott, Phi (after trading Streit),
Sjs, Stl (after Shattenkirk trade),
Tbl, Tor, Wpg.
So 22 teams have at best 2 d-men with 25 points and half of them (11) only have one.
Now tell me that you want to trade Beaulieu for a bag of puck or protect Benn instead of him again?
Note that there are
42 d-men older than Beaulieu in that list and only 14 who are younger.
If you offer me a trade for Beaulieu+ for Duchene then fine (anyway, as you can see, Col has
one d-men with 25 points so far).
Plekanec would most likely need to go the other way for SCap purpose.
Faulk, Parayko, Klinsgberg, Trouba, Rielly and Gotisbehere are about the same age as Beaulieu but they get first PP while Beaulieu was almost always behind Markov and PK/Weber.
Where would he be with same PP TOI?
So Benn or Beaulieu: choice seems clear to me.
I still love Benn as a bottom-6 and I also love him as a team player.
If Bergevin can make any deal with LV to keep him, fine with me.