No question that Nardella is killing it, but does he have that extra gear that’s required to be an NHL regular? I’m not sure yet. He didn’t look out of place in the pre-season, so hopefully his game can translate to one level higher. But I don’t yet see him as being on the same level as a Schmidt or Djoos (or other players they have/will let go and succeed elsewhere).
AA’s ceiling is still higher than any of our other D prospects, Fehervary included. The injury concerns are growing rather than shrinking, and if you look at 1st round NHL busts, injuries are a really common factor. But if he gets past that, he has tools that, simply put, no other D in the Caps stable has. He could be that dominant 2-way D that every team lusts for. Will he? That’s a harder question with a less rosy forecast.