GM Game 5 Discussion Thread

[hockeynorth]

Its always the same man

 

[Panda Bear]

NYI sends Leddy and a 2021 3rd to CGY for future considerations.

@SJSharks39

 

[hockeynorth]

Delete

 

[Gecklund]

NYI sends Leddy and a 2021 3rd to CGY for future considerations.

@SJSharks39

Confirm

 

[hockeynorth]

@TribalPhoenix are you here?

 

[hockeynorth]

Also @ujju2 really built EDM up and dipped... if you wanna sign free agents gotta do that bro

 

[hockeynorth]

So I'm getting like no calls on free agents

 

[belair]

lmao at arguing over a 1M cap hit increase in a fictional GM game

If I'm gonna play the game, I prefer to do it realistically.

The guy arguing this approved Dubois at 3 x 5. Not exactly a shining example of consistency.

 

[Gecklund]

If I'm gonna play the game, I prefer to do it realistically.

The guy arguing this approved Dubois at 3 x 5. Not exactly a shining example of consistency.

So you're not matching?

Dubois is about 1M lower than it probably should be but CBJ is a playoff team. He was sold on the promise of them adding more players and becoming contenders if he takes a discount. All Detroit did to convince Mantha was tell him how awful he was and how he isn't better than Larkin.

 

[hockeynorth]

If I'm gonna play the game, I prefer to do it realistically.

The guy arguing this approved Dubois at 3 x 5. Not exactly a shining example of consistency.

Everyone told him that one was bad

 

[Panda Bear]

If I'm gonna play the game, I prefer to do it realistically.

The guy arguing this approved Dubois at 3 x 5. Not exactly a shining example of consistency.

Dubois getting 3 x 5 is a load of hooey.

Mantha getting 5 x 6 is the absolute bare minimum. Get out of here with your "only 48 points" when it's all about prorating for healthy seasons in contract negotiations. If a player's injury, IR cap relief takes the pain away anyway.

 

[OB5]

If I'm gonna play the game, I prefer to do it realistically.

The guy arguing this approved Dubois at 3 x 5. Not exactly a shining example of consistency.

So are you matching?

 

[hockeynorth]

Lets hear those offers on:

Hampus Lindholm

and also....

Mitch Marner

 

[belair]

Dubois getting 3 x 5 is a load of hooey.

Mantha getting 5 x 6 is the absolute bare minimum. Get out of here with your "only 48 points" when it's all about prorating for healthy seasons in contract negotiations. If a player's injury, IR cap relief takes the pain away anyway.

Prorating production is how you end up with immovable contracts. There's a hell of a lot more that goes into negotiations than just a player's PPG average. More than what I'm bringing to the table as well.

As for your 5 x $6m, it's pretty much dead on what was first offered. And that contract was based on Larkin's deal that he signed coming off of a 63 point season.

Final offer was 3 x $6.5m, but the silly business prevails.

 

[Magic Mittens]

Big trade!


Roope Hintz
Denis Gurianov
Jake Oettinger
Jason Robertson
2021 2nd
2022 1st
2022 2nd
2023 1st


Patrick Kane @ 50%

Sacrificing the teams future, and was very hard to give up Hintz and Gury, but adding Kane will help this team become a top contender in the west

@flyersdad

 

[Peter Griffin]

Final offer was 3 x $6.5m, but the silly business prevails.

That should’ve been accepted honestly.

 

[hockeynorth]

Prorating production is how you end up with immovable contracts. There's a hell of a lot more that goes into negotiations than just a player's PPG average. More than what I'm bringing to the table as well.

As for your 5 x $6m, it's pretty much dead on what was first offered. And that contract was based on Larkin's deal that he signed coming off of a 63 point season.

Final offer was 3 x $6.5m, but the silly business prevails.

3 x 6.5 should’ve gone through imo, that’s just under the Tkachuk deal

 

[Panda Bear]

Prorating production is how you end up with immovable contracts. There's a hell of a lot more that goes into negotiations than just a player's PPG average. More than what I'm bringing to the table as well.

As for your 5 x $6m, it's pretty much dead on what was first offered. And that contract was based on Larkin's deal that he signed coming off of a 63 point season.

Final offer was 3 x $6.5m, but the silly business prevails.

You end up with immovable contracts when players fall off a cliff due to age (e.g. Ladd, Lucic) or get into that always injured but not injured enough zone where you can't LTIR them forever.

Whatever planet you're on where you can start an argument by saying that Mantha doesn't deserve anything around of 6.8m due to injuries is the unrealistic planet.

 

[Panda Bear]

According to @SJSharks39 Mantha's ask is $6.8m on a four year term. His career high in points is 48.

Was kinda hoping this game would be realistic.

^^^^^^^^^

 

[hockeynorth]

6.5 by 3 would’ve been fine

 

[belair]

So are you matching?

Not matching Fabbri. Happy to accept CGY's 2nd, which looks poised to be a very early round pick in the 2021 draft.

Mantha still under consideration. Though Montreal's 1st, 2nd and 3rd look mighty enticing.

 

[belair]

You end up with immovable contracts when players fall off a cliff due to age (e.g. Ladd, Lucic) or get into that always injured but not injured enough zone where you can't LTIR them forever.

Whatever planet you're on where you can start an argument by saying that Mantha doesn't deserve anything around of 6.8m due to injuries is the unrealistic planet.

I look forward to him signing his extension this summer. More likely than not his AAV will start with a five.

 

[Panda Bear]

NJD trades Will Butcher, Ty Smith and Seth Jarvis to ANA for Hampus Lindholm and Bo Groulx.

@hockeynorth

 

[flyersdad]

Big trade!


Roope Hintz
Denis Gurianov
Jake Oettinger
Jason Robertson
2021 2nd
2022 1st
2022 2nd
2023 1st


Patrick Kane @ 50%

Sacrificing the teams future, and was very hard to give up Hintz and Gury, but adding Kane will help this team become a top contender in the west

@flyersdad

Hawks confirm. We thank Patrick Kane for his years of service and wish him the best in Dallas.

 

[hockeynorth]

Anaheim confirms