I give Brodin the edge just based on pro leagues vs the CHL. The production doesn't compare well but the experience usually makes up for it.If I was to do a comparison in regards to hype/expectations/whatever, I'd have it:
Rossi ~ Granlund
Boldy > Coyle
Beckman ~ Zucker
Addison < Dumba
Lambos ~ Brodin (maybe an ever-so-slight edge to Brodin depending on if you bought into offensive upside and by how much)
Wallstedt > any of the goalies
It's also why I think Khusnutdinov is a real x-factor in the current pool vs the 2012 pool. His role seems to have diminished somewhat after SKA added Gusev, but at 19 he's looked right at home in the KHL. I don't think we had a good comparable in the 2012 group.