Didn't know much about this guy when we drafted him. He appears to be having a great season though. How would people rate him against his Flames property counterpart: Laurent Broissot.
Who do people perceive to be the better goalie prospect?
I like Gillies more. Maybe it's because I've seen Brossoit more often, so I have the ability to pick out little details that I can't with my limited watching of Gillies, but I defiantly like our American prospect more (I had the same feeling going into the 2012 draft - Gillies was a top 60 draft player for me and I wasn't sold on Brossoit yet).
Keep in mind too that I haven't seen Brossoit since he caught fire after being dropped from the WJC team.
The thing for me is how fast Brossoit drops. A number of times he's down in his butterfly really fast. Maybe I'm scared off by Karlsson, maybe it's because I'm not positive how well his ability to scramble will come work in higher leagues, but it is worrying when I see him. That said, Brossoit is also athletic and has that Kiprusoff type of tendency of not ever being fully out of a play.
He also seems a little bit dominated by his hot-cold streaks (as a Flames fan, I'm sure you've seen that in Cammalleri from time to time. Think like that), hence why he's seeing Jarry overtake him from time to time.
For Gillies, he's got a very level head. He's definitely a bit "quieter" in his play and keeps to his own. He'll peek through traffic well and comes out of his crease pretty well, something I really like in goaltenders as it tends to emphasize their confidence. Really, the biggest flaw is his puck handling, both on his stick and off the pads. He has a tendency to let shots off his pads go any direction they want as oppose to directing the rebounds into corners. I see a lot of Price's style in him (not quality. I'd be happy if Gillies makes the NHL. But in regards to his movements and mannerism, they look similar to me).
I'm not sure that it's saying much right now, as goalies are so volatile, but I think Gillies, though he's a "project pick", will be more likely to make the NHL. Again though, it's like just personal preference...Brossoit has a low chance given his draft position, while Gililes has a slightly better, but low chance.