Which kids? Trenin is for sure better offensively than Watson so there is no risk there. So who replaces Bonino, Turris and Granlund? You think asking Kunin, Tolvanen and Tomasino to do this is risky? Having 2 rookies in your top 9 isn’t risky.
Well.. Poile did just throw $20 mil out the door from his offense and while I agree the change was necessary I'm not sold on that this team is better than the team that didn't make the playoffs last season.
On top of that, why did Poile just buy out Turris if he isn't going to use that cap space on anything (addition by substraction?), because that 8 year penalty looks UGLY. Why didn't he re-sign Smith for that bargain deal, if he isn't going to use the available cap space on anything?
Trenin is better than Watson for sure, but with Bonino, Granlund, Turris and Smith, Poile threw 62 goals out the window. Kunin is good for about 15-20 goals on the 2nd line and we obviously need more goals from our top guys which Poile is banking on. Having two rookies in the top-9 isn't all that risky but there are waaay too many question marks on this team for it to be a contender.
How do we know Hoffman would perform that well here? We’ve seen that numbers drop for whatever reason.
Also to get better we just need to out perform the one they’re replacing
We don't. But Hoffman's probably the closest thing to a sure thing in the UFA market and on the trade market we could explore. On a one-year deal, we could overpay to get him and it wouldn't hurt us because we will have +$10 mil in the cap space after we sign Kunin.
We're light on forwards as it is and that's why I don't think that by signing Hoffman we'd be blocking the kids if that's the route Poile wants to go. We'd just be adding a proven scorer into the mix.