McFlyingV
Registered User
70 + is not very reasonable IMO. Here is a list of the best rookie seasons in the modern era:
Ovy - 106
Crosby 102
Malkin 85
Kane 72
So 70 looks like a stretch - more like 50 - 60
70 doesn't seem like a stretch at all when Mackinnon put up 63, Nuge was on pace for 69, and Yakupov was even prorated to 53. I don't think there is any question at all that McDavid is better than any of those players were when they came into the league the year they were drafted, and its quite likely he's actually currently better offensively than all those players are right now.