This is probably a topic of debate that will last a century, but I tend to think these are professionals and its up to them to get motivated to perform their best when needed, not necessarily on the coach to get them to play to their ability over all 82 regular season games. I have a hard time thinking they only get up when the coach gives them a proper speech, or threatens them with some punishment like benching. I think its natural that players take stretches of games off over a 6 month RS and a coach who beats them up over it won't last too long.We already know a coach cannot just bench everyone to make them ALL step up to their potential. We also know when this team plays with purpose, they can pretty much demolish anyone.
So yeah, on paper, this team should compete for a Cup. And a lot of people will blame TR if they don't compete properly. But I will be blaming some players like Kuzy or Holtby if we don't get a Cup worthy performance out of them. I just don't think its "Trotz vs Tood" when it comes to making Kuzy care, its up to Kuzy.