both big, stay at home, non-physical defensemen.
one was suited for the clutch and grab time (gill) the other for current times, skating, (carlo).
Carlo, like Gill, has yet to shown that he's anything more than a second pair d-men that you don't notice much on the ice.
solid, steady, dependable, reliable.
Gill never showed in his career any type of take charge attitude, anything impactful, just went about his business.
So far Carlo has showed the same. He's young and who knows if he will become assertive or dominant in any aspect of the game, but personality is personality.
so yeah, so far, its a fair comparison.