So Minny buys those two guys out for the expansion draft is that the consensus...
Has any team been ravaged worse than that team from the two expansion drafts
I don't agree with that consensus.
Compare the two situations
Without buyouts:
2021-2022 Suter (36) & Parise (37) Combined: 15.1m
2022-2023 Suter (37) & Parise (38) Combined: 15.1m
2023-2024 Suter (38) & Parise (39) Combined: 15.1m
2024-2025 Suter (39) & Parise (40) Combined: 15.1m
With buyouts:
2021-2022 dead cap hits: 4.7m
2022-2023 dead cap hits: 12.7m
2023-2024 dead cap hits: 14.7m
2024-2025 dead cap hits: 14.7m
The only way this is a bad move is if you think Suter (and Parise) were going to continue to be useful players for the next four years. People are looking at the cap hits and freaking out, but if both Suter and Parise are no longer NHL-quality players, you're looking at essentially 15.1m in dead cap for all four years. Plus you've got the added feature of them being locker-room leaders who would probably become increasingly bigger distractions as their ice time diminished (remember all the stories about Parise these playoffs?).
So in terms of their value to the team, Parise was already getting healthy scratched, and how long do you think Suter's body holds up after consistently leading the league in minutes. If you didn't buy them out you'd basically be praying they get perma-injured eventually and go on LTIR. Even in that case, that's a ton of money to have on LTIR.
The other option of course would be to trade them, but Parise likely had negative value even with retained salary, and Suter had a NTC he was extremely unlikely to waive (and also may have had less value than people think given the term left on his deal).
So from a Minny perspective, sure they lose Suter on the back-end, but they have the cap space to replace him for this season. And even if they kept him, they'd probably have to start looking for replacements for his ice time and role within the next 2-4 years. This gives them an extra 10m to fill Suter's role in year one, 2m+ in year two, and then an entry-level deal in years 3 and 4. If Guerin can find (and develop) a good young defenseman on a 3 year ELC which starts in 2022-23 or 2023-24, then this will work out perfectly.