The goat poses to be a real good 3rd line centre. I like him, but I don't think he's a better prospect than a lot of these guys, kapanen, brown, Johnson, and others all have higher potential.
Yeah ... in that sense, high skill scoring etc, for sure. The thing with the Goat for me though is that from having watched him in Junior, i feel like his overall game, beyond the scoring has Elite potential. His overall ability to drive the possession ... he makes plays that are felt all over the ice long after the play is made. He'll also be on the ice for every crucial face-off and kill all the big penalties.
Granted, the scoring ... without which, it is hard to place him above others. His shot can certainly use some work. The thing is, with his passing ability, i have to think that he'll put up assists along side talent that can finish, which he never really had in the Q. Furthermore, he has found a knack for parking in front of the net. If he is given to continue developing that, he will score a lot of garbage goals. David Clarkson scored 30 from there, and he's not exactly talented...
So sure, if Puzzles puts up an average of 20 points a year in the NHL, #4 is a bit high ... maybe in the #10 range makes more sense. If he averaged 60 points, he would be a franchise player. The difference that scoring stats can make to his impact cannot necessarily be said for the others (eg: Kessel is not a franchise player despite scoring 80, and neither would be Bozak or Lupul if they did ... maybe not even JVR).
I'm not yet convinced that the goat won't get to 40 in the NHL, simply because his passing ability, combined with a willingness to stand in front of the net, should the organization put him in a position to pursue that skill, could produce a fair share of production.
Of course, if he is buried as a 3rd line C behind the talents of Nylander etc, which would make total sense, he would have less opportunities to utilize getting those Garbage points. In all though, i do believe he will surprise some people as he continues to develop. I do hope he makes it into the top 10 of this poll, because by most any account, he really should be. ... even if 3rd line C is his resting place ... he'll be one of the most important players on the ice most nights.