Top 50 games PT 2

[Muzzinga]

216 Sonic Adventure 2: Battle 1 5 1
228 Burnout 3 Takedown 1 1 4 2
306 Vigilante 8 1 2 1
335 Timesplitters 3 1 1 1

Whoever picked these like me, reveal yourselves because i think we are meant to become best friends

looking at that big list, i definitely blanked on ssx tricky, that would have been around 6 or 7 on my list

 

[CanadianHockey]

My List:

1. Battlefield: Bad Company - 102
2. The Last of Us - 15
3. Tom Clancy's Ghost Recon - 136
4. Civilization V - 35
5. Counter Strike - 86
6. Portal 2 - 50
7. Batman: Arkham City - 66
8. Call of Duty: Modern Warfare - 26
9. Red Alert 2 - 124
10. NHL 99 - 323

 

[parabola]

Can't believe I was the only person to vote Myst. You guys are making me feel old.

Im surprised anyone remembered Myst regardless of how old you are.

 

[Teemu]

It was the best-selling computer game of all time until The Sims, if I recall.

On that topic, I was the only person to vote for The Sims as well.

 

[Muzzinga]

Im surprised Arkham Asylum didnt make the list. I didn't play many games on the 360/ps3 era, but that 1 was definitely a highlight

 

[Muzzinga]

thanks for doing this JESUS. I now have like 300 games I need to find time for to play

 

[Soliloquy of a Dogge]

My final list... geek arguments are always fun *grabs popcorn and watches*

1)Deus Ex (24)
2)Halo: Combat Evolved (22)
3)System Shock 2
4)Super Mario World (13)
5)Zelda: A Link to the Past (17)
6)Grand Theft Auto III (34)
7)Metal Gear Solid III (48)
8)KOTOR
9)Half Life 2 (12)
10)Red Dead Redemption (38)

 

[Punchbowl]

xxxx

 

[LickTheEnvelope]

Im surprised anyone remembered Myst regardless of how old you are.

I got some of those:

 

[Big McLargehuge]

Great work Trap.

Final results for me...
1. Grandia - 106th...only vote!
2. Final Fantasy VII - 14th
3. Chrono Trigger - 2nd
4. Nights into Dreams... - 162nd...only vote!
5. Super Mario World - 13th
6. Bioshock - 5th
7. Grandia II - 237th...only vote!
8. The Last of Us - 15th
9. Civilization IV - 31st
10. Sonic the Hedgehog 2 - 84th

 

[LSnow]

I guess. But i'm not really wrong. Bethesda took Fallout in a completely different direction. I haven't heard of anyone who was a fan of the Fallout franchise who liked Fallout 3. It was kind of an insult to the franchise.

I preferred FO3 to NV because it had better atmosphere. Neither came close to the originals.

 

[Necropolis]

So my list:

1. The Elder Scrolls III: Morrowind (30th)
2. Final Fantasy VIII (62nd)
3. Fallout 2 (39th)
4. Final Fantasy VII (14th)
5. Oddworld: Abe's Oddysee (187th)
6. Crash Bandicoot (181th)
7. Civilization IV (31st)
8. Final Fantasy VI (9th)
9. The Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim (37th)
10. Baldur's Gate (75th)

 

[LickTheEnvelope]

I preferred FO3 to NV because it had better atmosphere. Neither came close to the originals.

Setting for me. I thought Washington DC was more interesting than Vegas for that type of game.

NV is a better game though.

 

[Ceremony]

I was surprised Crash Bandicoot ended up so low. Thought it might have got some nostalgia votes. Another one I have never been able to finish...

... and I just remembered my other vote. I'm the only person who voted for Rayman 2? Now that's a travesty.

 

[Necropolis]

I was surprised Crash Bandicoot ended up so low. Thought it might have got some nostalgia votes. Another one I have never been able to finish...

... and I just remembered my other vote. I'm the only person who voted for Rayman 2? Now that's a travesty.

I thought that it'd be in the top-10 for sure. Didn't exactly go that way.

 

[Mischa]

Setting for me. I thought Washington DC was more interesting than Vegas for that type of game.

NV is a better game though.

I preferred Vegas over DC for settings. the casinos and stuff had a lot more style than the DC buildings and monuments imo(and especially the subway. not a fan). and i found the turf wars type of thing a much more compelling story. Bethesda seems to have a knack for making (what I consider) bland settings

 

[Butchered]

To the people who had BoF: DQ and III on their list, can we be friends

 

[SniperHF]

My list:
1) Rainbow Six 3: Raven Shield (NR)
2) Fallout 2 (39)
3) Fallout 1 (NR)
4) Gothic 2: Night of the Raven (NR)
5) The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time (1)
6) Unreal Tournament 3 (NR)
7) Deus Ex (23)
8) Baldur's Gate II: Shadows of Amn (32)
9) Command & Conquer: Red Alert. (NR)
10) Civilization IV (31)


Who voted for Gothic 1?
I think it was just Zodiac and I who voted C&C Red Alert.

Biggest surprise for me that didn't make the top 50 was not a single Resident Evil game.

 

[Zih]

1. Baldur's Gate 2 (#32)
2. Mass Effect 1 (#16)
3. Homeworld (NR)
4. Baldur's Gate 1 (NR)
5. Super Mario Bros 3 (#4)
6. Bioshock (#5)
7. Rome: Total War (NR)
8. Dragon Age: Origins (NR)
9. Half Life (#47)
10. Diablo 2 (#7)

Had I remembered Portal 1, it might've made my list. Somehow Homeworld isn't on the list at all even though I voted for it, so I assume that no one else voted for it which is a shame.

 

[Jasper]

1. Baldur's Gate 2 (#32)
2. Mass Effect 1 (#16)
3. Homeworld (NR)
4. Baldur's Gate 1 (NR)
5. Super Mario Bros 3 (#4)
6. Bioshock (#5)
7. Rome: Total War (NR)
8. Dragon Age: Origins (NR)
9. Half Life (#47)
10. Diablo 2 (#7)

Had I remembered Portal 1, it might've made my list. Somehow Homeworld isn't on the list at all even though I voted for it, so I assume that no one else voted for it which is a shame.

Homeworld is there, I noticed it and remembered the game when I saw it.

 

[Trap Jesus]

1. Baldur's Gate 2 (#32)
2. Mass Effect 1 (#16)
3. Homeworld (NR)
4. Baldur's Gate 1 (NR)
5. Super Mario Bros 3 (#4)
6. Bioshock (#5)
7. Rome: Total War (NR)
8. Dragon Age: Origins (NR)
9. Half Life (#47)
10. Diablo 2 (#7)

Had I remembered Portal 1, it might've made my list. Somehow Homeworld isn't on the list at all even though I voted for it, so I assume that no one else voted for it which is a shame.

#140 (1 third place vote), although I don't doubt I made some mistakes on this. There was one point where I marked down Super Smash Bros. instead of Super Mario Bros. and it took me forever to find out what I did wrong as to why the numbers weren't matching up.

Likewise to people, thanks for participating. I got a lot more responses than I thought I would, which only makes for a better list.

 

[Zih]

#140 (1 third place vote), although I don't doubt I made some mistakes on this. There was one point where I marked down Super Smash Bros. instead of Super Mario Bros. and it took me forever to find out what I did wrong as to why the numbers weren't matching up.

Likewise to people, thanks for participating. I got a lot more responses than I thought I would, which only makes for a better list.

Whoops, accidentally had Match Case on my Ctrl+F. My bad.

All in all I think the top 50 went about as well as you could expect. I don't see a single game in there that I think really doesn't belong. You can quibble about placement issues, but in this format I really don't consider those to be serious complaints.

Thanks to Trap Jesus for doing all of this.

 

[XX]

1. Deus Ex
2. Half Life 2
3. Portal 2
4. Half Life
5. Battlefield 2
6. The Last of Us
7. Shadow of the Colossus
8. Mass Effect 2
9. Call of Duty 4: Modern Warfare
10. World of Warcraft

My list. All made it except Battlefield 2. KOTOR? Warcraft 3? Shows the age of the average gamer here...

 

[tc 23]

Turns out I was the only one who voted for 3 of the 5 games on my list that didn't make top 50.

 

[Muzzinga]

My list. All made it except Battlefield 2. KOTOR? Warcraft 3? Shows the age of the average gamer here...

Or just the wrong genres?

No battlefield made the list, and Starcraft and Age of Empires 2 are the only RTS that made it (unless i missed 1)

KOTOR doesn't really have a direct comparable