Olympics: Team USA 2018 Roster Discussion

[TheBigThree]

Tram USA screwed up their team this fall...what makes anyone think things will be different in the Olympics?

They have matthews

 

[East Coast Icestyle]

Hockey Canada is an old boys' club, no way Matthews would make it (regardless of whether he'll be good enough or not)

Don't see how this is true at all. Canada has always switched up who it picks, or the last two Olympics would have seen the same rosters. Instead we saw Duchene, Tavares, Bouwmeester, Kunitz, Carter, etc.

 

[Deadly Dogma]

I really think that Eichel needs to be the main catalyst and best player on his line. That's when he seems to be at his best.

Makes sense, I obv don't see Eichel as often as you so when I think of Eichel my 1st thought is this burst type skating player. I guess I over look his playmaking in that I focus so much on his skating

 

[Nordique]

Cam Atkinson Olympics

How close is Cam Atkinson to making the US roster in 2018 (if NHL participates).

27 years old

20+ goal scorer the last 3 seasons.
On pace for 33 goals this season.

For comparison sake, he has more goals in the last 3 seasons than Oshie.

 

[Mattilaus]

Makes sense, I obv don't see Eichel as often as you so when I think of Eichel my 1st thought is this burst type skating player. I guess I over look his playmaking in that I focus so much on his skating

He needs the puck on his stick to be effective. It's why he isn't effective with Kane, because Kane likes to carry the puck. He works best with a grinder who can get the puck off the boards and a finisher/net front presence. From what I have seen J.G. also likes to carry the puck (which he should because he is a wizard). Just don't think there would be enough puck for the two of them on the same line.

 

[TOGuy14]

Politics. It's not unheard of for the young guys to have to wait their turn. He'd undoubtedly be ready talent-wise...just depends on the Good 'Ol Boys in charge.

Yes but Eichel is no more established than Matthews now, and given the amount of time until the Olympics why do you think Eichel will get the veteran treatment while Matthews will be made to "pay his dues"?

 

[GellMann]

They should make it and would be among the team's best players.

 

[BenG]

IMO, it would be between him and Backes with Backes getting the edge for his leadership, physicality, experience.

RW Depth:

Kane
Kessel
Wheeler
Backes/Oshie/Okposo/Kreider

 

[Nordique]

IMO, it would be between him and Backes with Backes getting the edge for his leadership, physicality, experience.

RW Depth:

Kane
Kessel
Wheeler
Backes/Oshie/Okposo/Kreider

That's where I'm at, Kreider or Atkinson for that 4th line. Cam is small, and that is a perceived weakness, but he plays in all situations, and has a good 2 way game.

 

[K Fleur]

Good god do I hope Backes is not on the 2018 US team.

 

[MNRube]

IMO, it would be between him and Backes with Backes getting the edge for his leadership, physicality, experience.

RW Depth:

Kane
Kessel
Wheeler
Backes/Oshie/Okposo/Kreider

Coyle also deserves mention here. Like Atkinson he has scored 20 G and is on pace for 30 this year. He's also big, physical and can play both RW/C and is trending upward in a big way.

 

[SenzZen]

I'd say he's about 14 months away.

 

[Advanced stats]

Coyle also deserves mention here. Like Atkinson he has scored 20 G and is on pace for 30 this year. He's also big, physical and can play both RW/C and is trending upward in a big way.

Atkinson is a lot more proven though.
Coyle is not on pace for 30 goals this season either.
Likely comes down to who's best next season and who has the best camp.
Right now Atkinson had the upper hand though.

 

[Rabid Ranger]

I was pushing for Atkinson on the World Cup team. I think if he keeps up this level of production he would be in consideration for the next Olympic team. Very versatile player with big ice skills.

 

[Aladyyn]

Lots of RW options for team USA, gonna be very interesting for sure

 

[Evergreen]

IMO, it would be between him and Backes with Backes getting the edge for his leadership, physicality, experience.

RW Depth:

Kane
Kessel
Wheeler
Backes/Oshie/Okposo/Kreider

Kreider is a LW

 

[bishop12]

Hockey Canada is an old boys' club, no way Matthews would make it (regardless of whether he'll be good enough or not)

I'm Canadians and yes this is so true. Sid was left of the 2006 team for this very reason.

 

[bishop12]

They also know how to win, 100% he would make it. Would they hold McDavid back?

Wouldn't hurt the Coach sees what he brings every night as well.

They konw how to win? lol it's because they have the best players..

 

[scan15*]

I'm Canadians and yes this is so true. Sid was left of the 2006 team for this very reason.

Toews and Doughty made it in 2010. They were 20 and 21.

 

[bishop12]

Toews and Doughty made it in 2010. They were 20 and 21.

Towes was 4 years out of his draft year.

Canada was and is an old boys club. They can afford to be because they always win. Other countries don't have that luxury.

 

[The Undertaker]

Yes they should but USA is ran by clowns so probably not. I fully expect JG, Matthews, Kessel, Galchenyuk, and maybe Eichel to be left home for guys like Callahan, Adelkadr, Backes, Dubinsky, Oshie, etc.

 

[34]

Eichel 1C
Matthews 2C

Matthews 1C
Eichel 2 C

Fixed that for you.

 

[SB84]

They are easily among the best 13 forwards so they will both make it. Whether or not they centre a line is another story but if I am projecting I think that Mathews plays wing and Eichel plays C. Matthews made a good impression at the World Cup of Hockey on McDavid's wing (he was initially pegged as the extra forward and works his way up to the top line) and team USA will take that into consideration.

Should be locks:
Kane
Gaudreau
Pavelski
Kessel
Wheeler
Pacioretty
Matthews
Eichel
Galchenyuk

Bubble Forwards:
Kesler (Unless he has a huge drop off next year I think he is very probable as he is dominant in the dot and provides a veteran presence)
Oshie
Saad
Larkin
Johnson
Trochek
Parise
Stepan

 

[sabrebuild]

Yes but Eichel is no more established than Matthews now, and given the amount of time until the Olympics why do you think Eichel will get the veteran treatment while Matthews will be made to "pay his dues"?

Except, that extra year of nhl experience. ..

 

[jBuds]

Matthews 1C
Eichel 2 C

Fixed that for you.

Center depth:


1. Eichel
2. Matthews

there we go


edit: joking...but if we are debating one more likely to move to wing, I'd guess Matthews, because he seems a bit more versatile positionally