If I am his agent I want a number that starts with a 5 if I am Chevy I want a number that starts with a 4. I went through a couple goalie contracts signed recently during their RFA years with trying to buyout UFA years.
All stats are as of the date the player signed their contract.
2014
Semyon Varlamov $5.900 AAV for 5 Years=$29.5 Million
9.18% of Salary Cap when signed
1 Year left of RFA Status when contract signed (Signed mid-season 2014)
Regular Season-189 GP .915 Save Percentage
Post Season-19 GP .915 Save Percentage
After extension signed during mid-season finished 2nd in Vezina Voting in 2014
Varlamov's agent hopefully got a raise himself after getting Varlamov this deal
2015
Sergei Bobrovsky $7.425 Million AAV for 4 Years=$29.7 Million
10.17% of Salary Cap when signed
1 Year left of RFA Status when contract signed (Signed mid-season 2015)
Regular Season-208 GP .918 Save Percentage (excluding Flyers 125 GP .924 Save Percentage)
Post Season-13 GP .890 Save Percentage
1st in Vezina Voting 2013
8th in Vezina Voting 2014
Contract was based off of being a Vezina winner and his dominance with the Jackets, deservedly so.
2015
Braden Holtby $6.100 AAV for 5 Years=$30.5 Million
8.36% of Salary Cap when signed
2 Years left of RFA Status when contract signed
Regular Season-178 GP .921 Save Percentage
Post Season-34 GP .936 Save Percentage
4th in Vezina Voting in 2015
Not much to add other than this probably closes the book on Helle getting anything starting with a 6.
2016
Frederik Andersen $5.000 Million AAV for 5 Years=$25.0 Million
6.85% of Salary Cap when signed
1 Year left of RFA Status when contract signed
Regular Season-125 GP .918 Save Percentage
Post Season-28 GP .916 Save Percentage
Was more consistent in his 3 years of NHL experience than Hellebuyck but only had more than 50 starts once in the 3 years. He also had a good playoff track record at the time of signing.
2016 (still had 1 year of term left on last RFA deal)
Jake Allen $4.350 Million AAV for 4 Years=$17.4 Million
5.96% of Salary Cap when signed
0 Years left of RFA Status when contract signed (still had 1 year of term left on last RFA deal)
Regular Season-99 GP .915 Save Percentage
Post Season-10 GP .902 Save Percentage
Inked his deal coming off of a .920 Save Percentage in 47 GP, not a bad deal for the Blues at all if you take his last year of RFA plus the 4 years of UFA=3.950 AAV for 5 years=$19.75 Million.
Current Situation to Monitor
Robin Lehner
1 Year left of RFA Status
Regular Season-201 GP .916 Save Percentage
Post Season-2 GP .920 Save Percentage
Finally
Connor Hellebuyck
2 Years left of RFA Status
Regular Season 121 GP .916 Save Percentage
Post Season-0 GP
Couple of items that we have in our favor. One thing that helps is Lehner is really the only upcoming RFA goalie with a track record and he can't touch Hellebuyck this year, was going to include Mrazek but he is pretty much a backup this year. The other is Hellebuyck having 2 years of RFA Status left. We can see above that Holtby had 2 years of RFA control left when he signed his deal and the Caps got him at almost 2% less of the overall cap compared to what the Jackets gave Bob.
I am not going to predict the future but as of today I think Frederik Andersen is the most fair comparison. If the cap does go to 80 Million and Hellebuyck was given the same cap percentage it would amount to an AAV of $5.480. Given that Hellebuyck has 2 years left of RFA I think we get a little discount there, so lets go with...
$5.250 Million AAV for 5 Years=$26.25 Million
Fun project for a Monday night
Nice work WiscoJet - just to put those numbers into perspective, if there's an $80M cap next year, here are the equivalents:
Bobrovsky (10.17%) = $8.136M AAV
Varlamov (9.18%) = $7.344M AAV
Holtby (8.36%) = $6.688M AAV
Andersen (6.85%) = $5.48M AAV
Allen (5.96%) = $4.768M
I think a lot depends on what happens in the playoffs - deep run, Cup win, could mean Bobrovsky numbers. As it is, anything under $6M AAV on a 4+ year deal is probably pretty reasonable.