edit> not really talking directly to you Troy, I should have multi-quoted to include OttMorrow's post right before you <
But the upside is such that it would be insane to get rid of him if he hadn't solidified an NHL spot this season. Just loony tunes as it's not like he's been behind in development. Would really suck to cut him loose then see him kicking ass for some other team next season so they could keep a likely 3rd pairing NHL dman (Joki) instead. He'd be a guy you have to figure out how to keep. Hopefully he keeps playing well consistently. Now him being involved in some kind of trade package is another deal entirely.
But imagine if he spent the rest of the season playing like he was before being sent down this last time. Then the decision isn't so easy.
It was always a pretty easy decision IMO. They do have enough roster spots without moving anyone since Nill has shown a willingness to retain 8 D to avoid placing anyone on waivers. He'd give himself at least a few months into the season before making a move just as he did with Rome last season.
You could easily start the season with Benn, Daley, Demers, Goligoski, Jokipakka, Klingberg, Nemeth, and Oleksiak.
The only move that would force their hand to make a decision immediately was adding another D. I think there's a good chance they do add a D if he's a potential Top 2 or Top 3 guy, but locating that guy has proven difficult the past 7 off-seasons already. I'm more hopeful that ever though this would be the summer. At that point yeah it'd be mildly difficult on him to decide between Benn, Jokipakka, and Oleksiak, but my guess is if Dallas lands the big fish D they want anyway ... one of Jokipakka or Oleksiak are going to be going the other way anyway making the decision unnecessary. Just my guess.
Still forced to make a decision, I just don't see Nill letting Jordie Benn push out a 22 year old giant in Oleksiak or by this summer almost 24 year old Jokipakka. Jamie is just too young to give up on and dump for no value and Jokipakka has done more for Dallas at the NHL level than Connauton had. He's shown real potential that is above and beyond either Connauton or Jordie Benn.
I guess the shortest way to some all that up is regardless of Oleksiak's last handful of games, I'd be pretty disappointed if it wasn't obvious Benn was the clear odd many out ultimately ... even just from a salary standpoint. As a UFA in only 18 months, he's going to blow Jokipakka and Oleksiak's salary out of the water. Neither one would likely touch the money he'll get until very close to their UFA years. Financially it just wouldn't make sense to keep him as an overpaid 3rd pair D.