Dotter
THE ATHLETIC IS GARBAGE
I think you misunderstood my position. Kronwall and Ericsson are terrible defenseman. They will help ensure the Wings finish towards the bottom of the standings next year.
Smith isn't good, and locking in another mediocre/bad defenseman for multiple years just doesn't make sense. With the state the Wings are in, a draft pick is far more useful than three more years of Brendan Smith.
The other defenders making mistakes are locked in for another 3, 4, 5 years no matter what we want done. Dekeyser just signed a 5 year deal, Ericsson is singed until 2020, Kronwall is signed until 2019.
No one is taking Kronwall or Ericsson off our hands. I'd love to have someone else take the Dekeyser contract, but you know Kenny isn't moving a Michigan kid when the rest of our defense is a mess.
So yeah, we don't want another guy getting overpaid who doesn't create much offense is just kinda there.
How long will the rebuild take? I suspect it's calculated out to start seeing an upswing by the end of Zetterberg's contract.
Honestly, signing Smith for 3 years or trading him for a 3rd/6th rounder really means little (if anything at all) to the overall rebuild. If KH can't get a decent return, might as well plug him for the next 3 years.
Now if KH refuses to trade Smith for offers of a top 15 overall pick and opt's to re-sign him to 7 years with a full NMC instead, I'd get your point.