Fenian24
Registered User
- Jun 14, 2010
- 10,414
- 13,598
The 6 vs 5 year thing is really the hill you're going to die on CDJ? lol it might as well be the same thing with his current production. 5 years is going to feel like 10.
But in the end if we agree that criticizing the production is fair, then let's just agree on that point and move on. Certainly not hard to criticize him there. Consider me focused on that until he turns it around. And if you're open to the idea that you were wrong about Beleskey, maybe you'll be open to Backes in 2 years. Or maybe I'll be the one who was wrong. I got Marchand wrong 3 years ago, look at him now. But I didn't get Hayes, Beleskey, Rinaldo, Liles, Quader and a host of others wrong. So somewhere in there a sliver of credit would be ayight. I think you get stuff right all the time.
I'm not sure of your opinion of McQuaid but if you think he is anything but a useful, heart and soul, solid defensive defenseman 5/6 D that any team would take you would be wrong. His salary is in the range of players that bring what he does.
But maybe we should have spent 3 million for 4 years on Alex Semin cause he's got skills and is super fast and great in EA